Praised be Jesus and Mary!
Dearest Rev. Father Angelo,
I’m writing to you because I’m in need of some clarification.
I read that, according to the German theologian Peter Hünermann, before the Council of Trent, Catholic theology considered the dissolution of the conjugal bond lawful, because it didn’t think that the indissolubility of marriage was absolute, recognizing as lawful even adulterous relationships consolidated over time.
Hünermann ends by saying that two great Doctors of the Church were of this opinion: Saint Thomas and Saint Bonaventure. My first question stems from this.
Is what the German theologian says true? Meaning that, until the Council of Trent, the Church didn’t consider the indissolubility of marriage absolute, tolerating adultery consolidated over time? Is it true that Saint Thomas and Saint Bonaventure argued this?
To be honest, I find it hard to believe.
Here’s the second question.
Even admitting that, before the Council of Trent, Catholic theology supported the lawfulness of breaking the marriage bond and adultery consolidated over time, is it possible to go back and regard as orthodox theological stances dogmatically repudiated by the Church (in this case in a dogmatic council like the one of Trent)?
Thank you for your kind consideration.
I wish you a good Holy Week and a Holy Easter (2018) of Our Lord.
Kind regards,
Marina


Dear Marina,
1. Personally, I’m not familiar with Hünermann’s thought outside of what has been reported by others like yourself.
So I will try to understand what he was trying to say by comparing it with Saint Thomas’ thought.

2. Saint Thomas doesn’t have any doubts about the indissolubility of marriage, especially after Jesus has said in Mk 10:11-12: ‘Whoever divorces his wife and marries another is guilty of adultery against her. And if a woman divorces her husband and marries another she is guilty of adultery too” and after the unanimous tradition of the Fathers.
Indeed, he writes: “Indissolubility belongs to marriage in so far as the latter is a sign of the perpetual union of Christ with the Church, and in so far as it fulfills an office of nature that is directed to the good of the offspring, as stated above.
But since divorce is more directly incompatible with the signification of the sacrament than with the good of the offspring, with which it is incompatible consequently, the indissolubility of marriage is implied in the good of the sacrament rather than in the good of the offspring, although it may be connected with both.
And in so far as it is connected with the good of the offspring, it is of the natural law, but not as connected with the good of the sacrament. (Supplement to the Summa Theologiae, 67, 1, ad 2).

3. Therefore, Saint Thomas can’t be cited in order to find in him a supporter of exceptions in this realm, not even in the case of the sterility of the marriage, because he writes: “Marriage is chiefly directed to the common good in respect of its principal end, which is the good of the offspring (…).
Hence marriage laws consider what is expedient for all rather than what may be suitable for one.
Therefore although the indissolubility of marriage hinder the good of the offspring with regard to some individual (because one could become a father or a mother with a different partner than the one they married – Ed.), it is proportionate with the good of the offspring absolutely speaking.” (Ib., ad 4).

4. Saint Thomas, however, wants to find the reason why Moses allowed the bill of divorce.
He justifies that permission by pointing out that the indissolubility of marriage is indeed part of natural law, but of secondary natural law and it’s among those norms that man doesn’t comprehend immediately, but in a second stage, following a reasoning process.
These norms can be obscured in the mind of some or even in the general society because of the hardening of heart caused by sin.
This was the reason why Moses conceded the divorce that, however, Jesus revoked by saying that things weren’t like that in the beginning.
Nor can our situation today be compared to that in Moses’ times, because we benefit now of the light brought by Christ.

5. For this reason, Saint Thomas says that “Although indissolubility belongs to the second intention of marriage as fulfilling an office of nature (regarding offspring -Ed.), it belongs to its first intention as a sacrament of the Church.
Hence, from the moment it was made a sacrament of the Church, as long as it remains such it cannot be a matter of dispensation. (Supplement to the Summa Theologiae, 67, 2, ad 3).
Even though God can dispense people in some cases, similarly as to what happens in the case of a miracle.

6. Similar to the bill of divorce was concubinage, which is contrary to the wellbeing of the offspring.
However, even concubinage could be the object of dispensation through some kind of miracle, as happened in the cause of Hosea to whom God said: “Go, marry a whore,
and get children with a whore;
for the country itself has become nothing but a whore
by abandoning Yahweh.” (Hos 1:2).
It’s a big leap to say, based on these attempts by Saint Thomas to understand the dispensations given in the Old Testament, that Saint Thomas supports the idea that in some cases a real marriage can be dissolved or that concubinage (which is a kind of adultery consolidated over time) can be approved in some cases.
It’s a stretch and a clear distortion of his thought.

7. Consequently, your second question is answered as well, because it does not stand.
Even if Saint Thomas and the precedent tradition had allowed divorce and concubinage in some cases, the declarations of the Council of Trent have more value because they are Magisterium of the Church: Solemn Magisterium, actually.
Therefore we would have to say “Roma locuta, causa finita” which means: since Rome has spoken, meaning the Magisterium has spoken, the dispute is finished. We can’t proceed any further.

I thank you for your trust, I recommend you to the Lord and I bless you.
Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish