Question

Dear Father Angelo,
My name is Daniele, I am 42 years old, converted to Christianity for two years (first practitioner of yoga and Zen meditation).
For two days I am “fossilizing” on Judas the Galilean or Gamala.
I have heard talks from prominent historians who identify him with Jesus Christ.
However, who was really Judas of Gamala?
Thanks for your time.
A hug.



The answer of the Priest

Dear Daniele,
1. Judas the Galilean is a personage quoted from the Acts of the Apostles 5,37. And he is also remembered by Josephus, the Jewish historian passed to the Romans.
He rebelled against the Roman authorities in Palestine on the occasion of the census for tax purposes carried out shortly after the death of Herod the Great.
This Herod was the one who wanted to kill baby Jesus at the time of the Magi.
2. The Acts of the Apostles speak of him in a speech by Gamaliel who spoke in the Sanhedrin when some, angry at the Apostles, wanted to put them to death.
Here is what the Acts say: “Then a Pharisee, named Gamaliel, doctor of the Law, esteemed by all the people, arose in the Sanhedrin. He gave orders to let them out for a moment and said: “Men of Israel, take good care of what you are about to do to these men.
In fact, Theudas arose some time ago, claiming to be someone, and about four hundred men joined him. But he was killed, and those who had allowed themselves to be persuaded by him were dissolved and ended up in nothing.
After him Judas the Galilean arose, at the time of the census, and led people to follow him, but he too ended badly, and those who had allowed themselves to be persuaded by him dispersed.
Now therefore I tell you: don’t mind these men and let them go. In fact, if this plan or this work were of human origin, it would be destroyed; but, if it comes from God, you will not be able to destroy them. May it not happen that you even find yourselves fighting against God!»” (Acts 5: 34-39).
3. How had things gone?
In the year 6 d.C. Sulpicius Quirinius began the census of Judea, recently annexed to the Roman Empire.
The people saw in the census the tangible proof that the nation chosen by God was sacrilegiously subjected to the dominion of the impure (such were considered the pagans).
Josephus in his Jewish War (II, 118) says that the great mass, persuaded even by distinguished priests, submitted and allowed themselves to be censored, and so did most of the Pharisees.
Instead, a certain Judas of Gamala, called the Galilean, resisted, who united with an authoritative Pharisee named Sadduc induced the villagers to rebellion by insulting them if they had tolerated, after God, to have mortal masters.The revolt was quelled by the Romans and about thirty years later Gamaliel still remembered it as a famous episode (see Acts 5:37).
4. The revolt of Judas the Galilean started the party of the Zealots, still present and active at the time of Jesus’ preaching.
They did not yield despite the first Roman repression.
Although dispersed and unknown to the Roman authorities, they always kept alive the spirit of an implacable political aversion against foreigners.
This aversion flared up openly in the final revolt in the 69-70s.
The Zealots were more intransigent Pharisees and for this very reason, they distinguished themselves from the more common Pharisees who in front of the Romans showed themselves passive and yielding.
They intervened suddenly, presenting themselves as flying squads with a short dagger in hand that the Romans called Sica. Hence the term of Sicari, given precisely to the Zealots.
They were the main culprits of the uprising of the 66-70s.
They disappeared when the Romans defeated the last outbreaks of the revolt and especially when the fortress of Masada was taken, whose tragic end is narrated by Josephus (Jewish War, VII, 252ss).
The more common Pharisees, on the other hand, passed the great test. In surviving Judaism they reorganized themselves according to the principles of the rabbinical schools and so they have remained.
5. The Sicari are mentioned incidentally in Acts 21:38 when Paul is asked: “So are you not that Egyptian who in recent times has stirred up and led the four thousand rebels into the desert?”.
Literally, assassins should be translated.
The Jerusalem Bible translates as “bandits”.
6. Jesus therefore has nothing to do with Judas the Galilean.
Gamaliel in reference to Judas the Galilean warns us to draw a lesson from him about the treatment to be reserved for the Apostles.
While I hope I have dispelled all doubts, I remind you to the Lord and I bless you.
Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish