Dear Dominican Friends,

I would like to ask a question on a subject that I cannot understand: the Creed reads regarding Jesus, “begotten, not made, of the same substance as the Father”. What does it mean that Jesus was begotten? This puzzlement arises from the fact that God is a same substance in three Persons existing before all ages. Perhaps it refers to the conception of Jesus by the Virgin Mary?

Thank you for your edifying work.

With affection

Mariangela


Dear Mariangela,

1. “Begotten, not made, of the same substance as the Father”, refers to the heresy of Arius.

Arius claimed that the Word, also called the Son, the second Person of the Holy Trinity, was not God but the first creature of God.

If so, Jesus would not be God made flesh and his redemption would not have infinite value.

2. The Council of Nicaea condemned Arius and said that the Word, the Son, is begotten, not made.

The Son or Word (second Person of the Holy Trinity) is the thought of God.

Now, thought we also call concept, that is conceived, because we beget it, in our minds.

3. We also apply this procedure to God: His Thought is begotten by Him and is His own divine substance.

For this reason, we say that God’s Thought (Word or Son) is “God from God, light from light, true God from true God.”

And we add, “begotten, not made,” precisely because He is God.

4. Therefore Jesus in His divine Person is begotten of the Father before all ages.

The formula of the Creed refers to this and not to the fact that the Word was begotten by Mary.

5. Mary gave the Word human nature. The body and soul that the Word, as true man, assumed were created.

6. In conclusion: Jesus, as God, is begotten by the Father.

As man, he is begotten by Mary.

Goodbye to you now, I remember you to the Lord and bless you.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian