Hello everyone, and peace be with you, Father Angelo.
I have always loved the figure of Mary, the mother of Jesus.
While reading, I came across an author who declared that “Mary, with her virginity, defeated all heresies”!
What does this mean, and why is it so important to our faith?
Thank you Father Angelo for your reply. Peace be with you all.
Priest’s answer
Dear Friend,
1. When I was a novice in the Dominican Order, in addition to the choral celebration of the entire Liturgy of the Hours with the community, the novices recited the entire Office of Our Lady twice a week in the novitiate chapel.
At the end of the psalmody of the third hour, we all said the following antiphon together: “Gaude, Maria Virgo, cunctas haereses sola interemisti in universo mundo“, “Rejoice, O Virgin Mary, for thou alone have destroyed all heresies in the whole world.”
As you can see, the antiphon is broader than the author you read would have reported. He links the overthrow of all heresies to Mary’s virginity alone. The antiphon, however, applies the defeat of all heresies to the Virgin Mary, in all her perfections.
2. And it is precisely by reviewing Mary’s four perfections that I wish to demonstrate in a more general manner the intimate union of Jesus with his mother, fully convinced of what St. Thomas Aquinas once stated: “Christ’s humanity and the Virgin’s motherhood were so connected to each other that anyone who erred about one also had to err about the other.” (Commentary on the Sentences, III, d. 4, q. 2, a. 2).
The four perfections of Mary dogmatically sanctioned by the Church’s magisterium are the following: she is Mother of God, Immaculate, Ever-Virgin, and Assumed into Heaven.
3. She is proclaimed Mother of God, due to the mystery of the Holy Trinity and the divine person of the Word.
She is Mother of God because God assumed a human body from her. And just as our mothers, although they gave us only a body because the soul was infused by God, generated our person and not just our body, so Our Lady, although she gave Christ a human body, is nevertheless fully Mother of Christ, Mother of the divine person of the Word, of the only-begotten Son who became incarnate.
This recalls the condemnation of Nestorius by the Council of Ephesus in 431, who asserted that in Christ there were two persons, the human and the divine person of God. If Christ had redeemed us only with his human person, His sacrifice would not have infinite value and could not embrace all men.
4. At the same time, reference is made to the Incarnation against every form of Docetism, another heresy that attributed to Christ only a likeness or appearance of human nature, but not a true human nature. This heresy denied not only the Incarnation but also the real Passion and Death of Our Lord.
At the same time, the value of the Eucharist was denied, through which Christ makes himself present with his true Body and Blood, as well as his Soul and Divinity.
5. Since it is Immaculate, that is, entirely holy, it touches upon the dogma of original sin, which has infected all humanity, and also touches upon the dogma of the necessity of grace for salvation and for performing meritorious works for eternal life.
Thus, the heresy of Pelagius, who asserted that man can save himself by his own efforts alone, is defeated. Jesus is the exemplar and model to imitate, but not the one who purifies our sins and sanctifies us.
6. Since she is ever Virgin, the conception of Jesus touches upon the mystery of the Holy Trinity, because it is through the power of the Holy Spirit that Our Lady becomes Mother. And it also touches upon the divinity of Jesus Christ, because the One to be born will be called the Son of God.
Even since she is a virgin in childbirth, this demonstrates the divinity of the One who gives birth. It is He who performs in Mary the miracle of giving birth to Him without violating her virginity.
Likewise, the Scriptures confirm that Christ, the Messiah, would fulfill the prophecies: “the virgin shall be with child, and bear a son” (Isaiah 7:14).
Since she is a virgin after childbirth, this demonstrates that she gave birth in time to the Only-Begotten Son of the Father, and at the same time, the reason why God created and redeemed us: so that we might become by grace what the Son, what the Only-Begotten is by nature. Because He, the Only Begotten Son of the Father, who came into the world as the only begotten Son of the Mother, would become the firstborn of a multitude of brothers (cf. Rom 8:29). True brothers because the same holiness of the Only Begotten Son of God circulates through participation in their souls. This is against the Lutheran heresy according to which grace does not transform man, but leaves him intrinsically corrupt, so that even if he does his duty, he sins mortally.
6. Inasmuch as she is Assumed into heaven, it refers to the resurrection of Christ, who rose to merit resurrection for us too. Thus, all eschatological truths are reaffirmed, including that of Purgatory, from which she is perfectly exempt because of her sublime sanctity.
7. What I have written is only a little, but it is enough to understand the truth that in Mary, alone, lies the refutation of all errors, all heresies.
Yes, St. Thomas Aquinas was right when he stated that “Christ’s humanity and the Virgin’s motherhood were so connected to each other that anyone who erred about one also had to err about the other.” (Commentary on the Sentences, III, d. 4, q. 2, a. 2).
Thank you for the question, I bless you, I wish you all the best, and I remember you in my prayers.
Father Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

