Hello, Father Angelo,

My name is Alessandro and once again I am pleased with your pastoral work, you carry it out masterfully. God bless you, and bless your Order too.

I would like to ask you a question about Trinitarian theology.

Well, I would like to ask you whether the difference between generation and procession in the immanent Trinity is an actual difference, or it is only a virtual difference or a difference in reason, only due to the creaturely limit, either of thought or of language, similarly to what happens, for example, with the divine prerogatives (omnipotence, omniscience, immutability, etc.) which we tell apart in a virtual way, but which, given divine simplicity, are actually one and the same thing, which is God himself. Therefore and consequently, one could also ask: if there is an actual distinction between generation and procession, how can it be reconciled with the same divine simplicity, according to which God is a single Pure Act.

In “De Trinitate”, St. Augustine the great does state such a distinction, and confesses that it is difficult to identify it (De Trinitate, 27.48). I wonder, what do other great authors of patristic say? And what do the canonized mystics say?

Thank you very much, my greatest Christmas wishes to you and the Order

Answer from the priest

Dear Alessandro,

1. in the profession of faith, the Creed, there is a point where we say: “I believe in the Holy Spirit… who proceeds from the Father and the Son”.

By procession, we mean a movement from one point to another.

In God there is something that proceeds from the Father, and it is his divine thought. And there is also the Holy Spirit who proceeds from the Father and also from the Son: it is his love, the One we call the Holy Spirit.

2. Now, it must be stated right away that in God there is no movement, no transition.

Otherwise, we would conclude that God moves to acquire a perfection that he does not yet possess.

If this were the case, he would no longer be God, he would no longer be the most perfect Being, Creator and Lord of heaven and earth.

3. It is Jesus who speaks to us about it and introduces us to a deeper knowledge of the mystery of God, of the Holy Trinity.

In fact, Jesus speaks of a specific movement, of a specific procession, when he says: “for I came from God and am here; I did not come on my own, but he sent me” (Jn 8:42).

How did he come? How does he proceed from the Father?

Theologians and the Magisterium of the Church say: through the intellect, in the act of knowing that is proper to the intellect.

Knowledge in the intellect is like conceiving, giving life, giving birth to a thought.

This is why we speak of generation and it is said that the Son is the divine intellection or knowledge that proceeds from the Father.

The Son, divine knowledge, is a spiritual and perfect reproduction of the known reality, of God.

This movement or procession, as it can be seen, is in the manner of generation.

This is why he is called Son.

4. Likewise, Jesus says: “When the Advocate comes whom I will send you from the Father” (Jn 15:26).

Here is the second procession which takes place through love.

God, in fact, knowing himself in the Word (the Son, the Logos), loves himself.

This love with which God loves himself is the Holy Spirit.

The Holy Spirit, therefore, proceeds from the Father and the Son as from a single source.

5. Having clarified what and how many processions there are within the Holy Trinity (that which you signify with the words Immanent Trinity), the question remains whether those two processions are actual or they are just a manner of speaking.

Certainly, they are actually distinct because there is a starting point (if one can call it that way) and a point of arrival.

But since in God everything is one, the distinction is logical or intellectual.

But not just logical, because it has a foundation in reality.

6. Just like the divine attributes you mentioned.

The attributes of God (omnipotence, omniscience, truth, goodness, mercy…) are all identified with the divine nature. Indeed, they are the very divine nature. And yet, they set themselves apart from each other because they are different.

A bit like when we say that the same person is a priest, a doctor, an artist.

Those qualities are distinct from each other from the point of view of reason, but not from the point of view of reality, because in our case the same person is a priest, a doctor, and an artist.

7. In conclusion, the two processions are distinct from each other, but not as separate realities because in God everything is one.

Which is why what is said of a divine Person is said of the whole Trinity.

In a word, they differ from the point of view of the thinking reason, but not from the point of view of reality.

Thank you for the question.

Above all, I thank you for the very pleasant wish you sent: that God may bless me and bless the Holy Order to which I belong.

I wish you all the best, I bless you, and I remember you in prayer.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish Portuguese