Dear Father Angelo,

I’ve been following your very interesting column for a short time, perhaps because my age (70 years) leads me to reflect more on the truly important things in life. Among others, I have a doubt concerning the degree of freedom and, consequently, of responsibility that each of us has in doing evil and, vice versa, the degree of merit in doing good. This doubt derives from the observation, which I believe can be shared, that there are people who are born with a mild temperament and are considered “good”, inclined to observe the rules, and others instead with a difficult, rebellious character, unwilling to be guided and advised . If this is true, one should suppose that the former are facilitated on the path to good,we would say without their merit, while the latter would be penalized from the outset. However, there is probably something in all of this that escapes me.

 Thank you if you can clarify my ideas on this. I also wish he would remember me in his prayers.

 With kindest regards.

 Anthonio

Answer from the priest

Dear Antonio, 

1. Your observations are spot on. St. Thomas Aquinas also kept them in mind and recognized that in single individuals there are some particular tendencies, good or bad, which dispose more easily to act in one way than in another.

 2. Here are his exact words, “In respect of the  individual nature some are disposed either well or ill to certain virtues on the basis of the disposition of the body… In this way one man has a natural aptitude for science, another for fortitude, another for temperance” (St. Thomas, Summa Theologica, I-II, 63, ). 

3. For St. Thomas it is only about inclinations, not yet about virtues. He says that “they come from nature as aptitude, but not in their perfect state” (Ib.). To make them blossom and make them virtuous, it is necessary to want it. They do not flourish spontaneously, as happens with vegetable realities or instinctive movements, but require a human act, the intervention of freedom, an election, a personal consent towards the good.

4. It is always with freedom, with election, with the will that virtues are generated in the human soul. It is important to underline the need to become masters of these inclinations, because otherwise, instead of becoming virtuous, one loads oneself with enormous defects. It can be seen in some men who are austere by nature, who become insensitive and hard, and in others, who are meek and patient by nature, who instead become reluctant to the calls of fortitude. 

5. What you observe about virtuous inclinations must be said equally for the inclinations to evil which are naturally more rooted in some people. Here the effort to become virtuous becomes even greater, but certainly meritorious.

 6. The case of St. Francis de Sales is well known, the saint of meekness, who was not born meek, and with the virtue of meekness incorporated. He became a saint with the help of grace. We read that, endowed with marked sensitivity, he was prone to mood swings and outbursts of anger. He was “impulsive and fiery.” If he was insulted, “he changed color and his face became inflamed.” So contemporaries say about him. One of his biographers, E. J. Lajeunie writes, “Francis de Sales was a true Savoyard, usually calm and sweet, but capable of terrible tempers; a volcano under the snow. Vaugelas understood him to say that by nature he was very quick to get angry, but that he undertook to correct himself every day. With this lively and sanguine temper, his habitual gentleness was often tried; often anger boiled in his head like water in a pot on a fire! He was very hurt by insolent and unpleasant words, and by vulgar gestures. (…). In 1619 in Paris, he confessed that he still had fits of anger in his heart and had to rein in the reins with two hands! ” (E. J. Lageunie, St. François de Sales. L’homme, la pensée, l’action. t. II, p. 118-119).

7. But here’s his secret, “I made a pact with my tongue not to say a word when I was angry. By the grace of God I was able to have the strength to curb the passion of anger, to which I was naturally inclined.”

 8. You say: some would be facilitated at the start. But if we keep in mind that the sentence on our life will be pronounced by God who searches hearts, we will see that in the end some of the first will be considered last and some of the last will be first. What matters in the end is God’s judgment. For this we understand even better the admonition of Our Lord, “Stop judging  and you will not be judged. Stop condemning and you will not be condemned. Forgive and you will be forgiven” (Lk 6:37). “because man sees the outward appearance, but the Lord looks into  the heart” (1 Sam 16:7). 

I bless you, I wish you well, and I remember you in prayer. 

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish Portuguese