Question
Good evening Father Angelo,
Thank you for your precious work on this website. There are many questions inside my head and I am searching for an answer to all of them.
Christian fasting: some time ago –I was in Medjugorje– I heard about the importance of supporting prayer with fasting. Starting from that moment, I decided that I should include fasting in my christian life, because I am convinced that it is really good. The problem is that I could not find enough information regarding this practice.
At first, I thought that one way to achieve fasting was to abstain from cigarettes on certain days, rather than fasting with just bread and water. This is because I believe I am more attached to cigarettes than food. Then, looking for an answer here and there, I read that it is still important to fast with bread and water, even if at first it may not seem like a big renunciation, because in fact it touches something of vital importance, that is, nourishment. Is this correct? In other words, should I stick to bread and water as fasting, or should I concentrate on the things that are hardest for me to give up?
Then I read that love and charity are of fundamental importance in fasting. I wonder if it makes sense to fast anyway, even if at the moment I feel I lack these virtues, or at least, I do not feel them very much. Instead of fasting, should I ask first to be invested with Christ’s love again? Does it make sense to fast for another person, that is, asking the Lord to accept my fasting as a small prayer for someone else? The difference between prayer and fasting is unclear to me in this case.
One last thing about fasting: I have read on a website that the days for fasting indicated by Mary Most Holy are Wednesdays and Fridays, so that we can receive the Holy Eucharist on Thursdays, and for other reasons. But I also know that secrecy is important. Now, if I could only fast in secrecy on Saturdays and Sundays, could I do so even if Sunday is a feast day? I ask this because I am an off-campus student and during the week everyone is at home but often not at the weekend. Perhaps, I could still try on Wednesday and Friday, trying not to be seen, but it would still be difficult for me to explain in the eventuality somebody asks me why I am not eating. At the moment, since I could not make up my mind, I am fasting when I am alone.
I think that I will send you the other questions another time: there is already a lot in this message that I will have to think about.
I thank you in advance and I accompany you in my prayers.
Priest’s answer
Dear friend
- Regarding fasting, it is necessary to establish something very important: that
fasting is not the aim of Christian life, but it is a means to an end.
- The aim of Christian life is charity, which consists in loving God and your neighbor with the very heart of God.
Fasting is one of the means that serves to preserve and revive charity.
- Fasting is intimately linked to charity.
The reason is the following: charity essentially consists in loving, that is, in giving. Therefore, fasting is not done to hoard, but rather to help us become detached from ourselves and live our lives by making them a continuous gift of ourselves.
- It is immediately clear that Christian fasting is embedded with joy, because although it is a privation, it is an act of love, a gift.
“It is more blessed to give than to receive.” (Acts 20:35)
- Having said this, one might wonder what the scope of fasting is.
It undoubtedly touches the area of gluttony, which is that of eating and drinking. We are all naturally attached to eating and drinking, because these two actions are fundamental to our survival. But there is no doubt that the pleasures associated with certain foods and drinks can transform into a dependency that leads us to eat more than we need, and to take drinks that can cloud the clarity of mind.
Hence, the need to regulate and sometimes even to ‘chastise’ oneself.
- By extension, fasting is expressed in other areas of life where there may be disordered attachment.
- So, for gluttony, as well as for the other spheres of life, the first fast consists in abstaining from all kinds of disorder, namely sin.
To be more explicit, fasting should be exercised in the sphere of the seven deadly sins: pride, greed, lust, wrath, gluttony, envy, and sloth.
- Understood in this way, fasting should always be done, even on feast days.
- In addition to this, fasting –especially in the strict sense of the term– also has a penitential significance, and therefore one of expiation and reparation for one’s own faults, and for those of others, because in the bond of charity we are all one. Therefore, the Church intervenes with its discipline.
An important observation: fasting is a matter of means, and the psycho-physical complexity of people is absolutely individual and it is not possible to establish equal measures for everyone. Therefore, the Church prescribes it in minimum forms, and only for two days a year, Ash Wednesday and Good Friday, and under certain conditions.
The Church knows that some people cannot fast, but they rather need to eat in order to do some heavy work, to restore their health, or to be strong enough to perform their duties properly.
- Eating only bread and water is not in the Precepts of the Church.
For some it may be excessive and against all forms of common sense and prudence.
The Church leaves it to the discretion of individuals, but recommends being enlightened and guided by the indications of one’s confessor or spiritual guide.
In the monastic tradition, fasting is carried out on two days a week: Wednesday (in memory of Judas’ betrayal) and Good Friday (in memory of Our Lord’s crucifixion and death).
- In addition to its expiatory and penitential meaning, fasting also strengthens one’s prayer.
In this sense, David fasted when the child he had from Bathsheba was seriously ill (2 Sam 12:16).
Animated by a more lively charity, fasting becomes a stronger cry to God. It can therefore be done for one’s own needs but also for those of others.
- Fasting helps to better prepare for the feast days, to prepare ourselves to live the mysteries of Christ’s life with greater purity of soul and body, and to receive the graces which the Lord has decreed to give us.
- Coming to your case, I would say that you should discuss the modalities and times of fasting with your confessor or spiritual father.
It is also a very good and meritorious fast not to do it on one’s own, and to give up pretending to know more than your confessor by judging him too lax.
- Let me remind you that the Church imposes no fast on feast days.
- Certainly, even on feast days we are not exempt from charity, and therefore, from many small sacrifices that unite us more closely with the Lord.
Still, in case of repentance fasting, I think it is right to join the ecclesial community that expresses its joy not only in receiving the dew of heaven, but also in welcoming with a certain abundance the gifts of the earth (“de rore coeli et de pinguedine terrae”, Gen. 27,28).
Thank you for drawing attention to this aspect of the Christian life, which tends to be neglected. Thank you also for your prayer, which I gladly reciprocate and bless you.
Father Angelo
Translated by Sergio Prezioso
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

