A case has caught my attention for some days, and yet I cannot see a comprehensive answer, despite drawing on my knowledge and books.
I present to you my doubt which pertains to the passage from the Gospel Luke 4:14-30.
It deals with Jesus, who entered the synagogue in Nazareth on the Sabbath, and who read the passage from the prophet Isaiah, stating that the Scriptures had been fulfilled in Him. Upon hearing this, the present ones filled with fury because Jesus would have blasphemed,
“and led him to the brow of the hill on which their town had been built, to hurl him down headlong. But he passed through the midst of them and went away.”
Now, I will briefly outline my doubts:
1. According to very recent archaeological research, at the time of Jesus, Nazareth did not exist or at most was a small hamlet of a few inhabitants, and certainly, there was no synagogue;
2. “They led him to the brow of the hill … to hurl him down”. Nazareth is not located on a hill; there are no cliffs or ravines where it could happen. For this reason, many scholars believe that Jesus of Nazareth does not refer to the town of Nazareth, but rather to Jesus’ personal state: Nazorean. Furthermore, at that time the fraction of Nazareth was far away from the Sea of Galilee where Jesus spent much of his mission. Therefore, recent historical research suggests that the town of Nazareth (located on a hill with a necessity for a brow), referred to the city of Gamala, which was thriving at the time, where there was a synagogue, just about three miles from the Sea of Galilee. This would explain how Jesus could daily go to the Sea of Galilee and then return to his town, which would be much more complicated with Nazareth, located about 20 miles from the Sea of Galilee.
I hope I have been clear in outlining my questions. Thank you for the time you will dedicate for me, I greet you with esteem and affection.
Lawyer Antonio
The Priest’s answer
Dear,
1. The evangelist Luke writes: “In the sixth month, the angel Gabriel was sent from God to a town of Galilee called Nazareth” (Luke 1:26). It was the sixth month of Elizabeth’s pregnancy.
Nazareth is in Galilee, the northernmost province of Palestine, and it is perched on a hill a thousand feet above sea level. It is presented as a city. At the time of Jesus, it was a small village or little more.
It is never mentioned in the Old Testament.
Nazareth means city of flowers.
There is no doubt that the name Nazarite means bud.
But, no doubt as well that this also fits for the man who was known as an inhabitant of Nazareth, the city of flowers.
The similarity between Nazareth and Nazarite (which means consecrated of the Lord) casts no doubt on the reality of the city of Nazareth.
2. According to St. Luke, who accurately investigated and like one historical research, Nazareth had its own synagogue, and it was there that Jesus began His preaching.
That Nazareth had a synagogue is beyond dispute. José Luis Martin Descalzo, in his monumental work on Jesus of Nazareth, writes: [tr.] “We can be absolutely certain that the synagogue of Nazareth—the ruins of which are still known today—was one of the vital centers of Jesus’ childhood” (Life and Mystery of Jesus of Nazareth, p. 212).
3. On the widespread diffusion of synagogues, Descalzo writes: [tr.] “Indeed, for nearly three centuries the synagogue had occupied a prominent place in the religious life of Israel. It was during the exile, when they could not flock to Jerusalem, that the faithful began to gather in homes or private spaces to discuss the law and history of their people.
Since then, synagogues had multiplied.
At the time of Christ, there was certainly no village, however small, that did not have a fine or modest synagogue.
In Rome, the Jewish exiles owned no fewer than thirteen” (Ib., p. 396).
4. We know that the people of Nazareth did not welcome the Lord when He returned with the fame of so many miracles.
They expected Jesus to perform miracles among them too. But because of their lack of faith, He performed none. For this reason, the sacred text says: “When the people in the synagogue heard this, they were all filled with fury. They rose up, drove him out of the town, and led him to the brow of the hill on which their town had been built, to hurl him down headlong. But he passed through the midst of them and went away.” (Luke 4:28-30).
5. About the brow of the hill from which they intended to hurl Jesus down, biblical scholar Marco Sales writes: [tr.] “They probably led Jesus to the place where the Maronite church stands today, in the southwest corner of the city, where there is a precipice 33 to 40 feet deep. They intended to take Him to justice and kill Him.”
6. Marie-Joseph Lagrange says: [tr.] “When it comes to determining the location of the brow which they intended to hurl Jesus down from, we should not look for it at the highest point of modern Nazareth that, but at the ancient and modest Acropolis, where it rises above the eastern valley” (The Gospel of Jesus Christ, p. 15-16).
7. Considering what I have written, many statements you have read have no basis in history, geography, or archaeology.
As you can see, it is necessary to tread carefully when you hear statements that conflict with what is written in the Gospel and has always been handed down. It is necessary to verify them, as you asked for in your email.
I bless you
Father Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

