Good morning, Father Angelo,

I am a young philosophy student, and I’m interested in Catholic theology and Christian theology in general; being an avid reader of the “A Priest Answers” column on the “Dominican Friends” Telegram channel, I came across the following article: https://www.amicidomenicani.it/en/how-old-are-angels-since-i-converted-i-have-learned-many-things-in-nine-years-then-who-knows-how-many-the-angels-have/

Notably, the passage that struck me was this: “As soon as they were created, they immediately saw everything. They entered eternity.

At their creation, many adored and loved God, their Lord, others rebelled at that same moment.”

After reading it, at once I asked myself: how is it possible that some of the angels, who as soon as they were created enjoyed God’s vision, and therefore omniscience and foreknowledge, chose to rebel anyway? Could it be that they didn’t foresee the consequences of rebelling against God? Why would Lucifer choose to leave his Lord behind to become a fallen angel, crushed by divine power?

Waiting for your kind and enlightening answer, I wish you all the best.

Marco


The Priest’s answer

Dear Marco,

1. According to St. Thomas, angels were put in the position of meriting or demeriting.

Therefore, in the first instant, angels were created in grace, having a supernatural knowledge of God, but not yet the beatific vision.

In the following instant, they either enjoyed beatitude or the consequences of rebellion.

Although they did not have the beatific vision and therefore did not enjoy divine omniscience, they nevertheless had a clear understanding of the consequences of their choice.

2. There is no dogmatic ruling on the matter of the two instants.

St. Thomas says that the opinion that is more probable and more in harmony with the teachings of the Saints is “that the devil sinned at once after the first instant of his creation. This must be maintained if it be held that he elicited an act of free-will in the first instant of his creation, and that he was created in grace; as we have said. For since the angels attain beatitude by one meritorious act, as was said above, if the devil, created in grace, merited in the first instant, he would at once have received beatitude after that first instant, if he had not placed an impediment by sinning.

If, however, it be contended that the angel was not created in grace, or that he could not elicit an act of free-will in the first instant, then there is nothing to prevent some interval being interposed between his creation and fall” (Summa Theologica, I, 63, 6).

3. The rebel angels were the makers of their own hell.

Just as it happens to the man who chooses to go to hell by his own actions, so it happened to the angels as well.

If hell is man’s self-exclusion from communion with God, as the Catechism of the Catholic Church says, the same must also be said of the fallen angels.

They did not find themselves slung into hell without their knowing.

For them too, hell was a choice, and an even clearer one than any man can make.

4. How is that possible if the angels knew about it?

I can answer you with the same words that the Catechism of the Catholic Church says in regard to temptation suffered by man: “It is a great mystery that providence should permit diabolical activity, but ‘we know that in everything God works for good with those who love him’ (Rom 8:28)”.

I bless you, wish you well, and remember you in my prayers.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish Portuguese