Question
Hi.
One question about a couple married in the Town Hall: he divorced from a Catholic religious marriage, she was unmarried and now they have two children.
Why cannot they take communion? May they receive other sacraments?
It is said that in America, after divorce, remarried people can.
The answer of the Priest
Dear,
1. the answer is simple: he, although divorced, was united in sacramental marriage with a woman who became his wife.
He promised to be faithful to her in good times and in bad.
He even waited for the moment when the priest, who blessed their wedding, said: “What God has joined, let no one put asunder”.
On his wedding day, therefore, he sanctioned a very special pact with his wife.
At a certain moment, after various vicissitudes, he went, dedicating his life to another woman.
Evidently, that betrayed the pact he made.
2. Now, he wishes to receive Holy Communion, the nourishment given us to be faithful to our duties.
But which is this man’s duty? That of dedicating his life to his wife or to another?
Dedicating one’s life to another woman is permanent adultery.
Therefore, in my opinion the exclusion of divorced and remarried has a clear reason: can Holy Communion be given to a person so that he is faithful to his permanent adultery? Obviously not.
3. Now however, things became complicated because two children were born from the adulterous union and these two children claim the simultaneous presence of their father and their mother.
And to ensure their parent’s presence is a duty, even though they are not husband and wife before God.
4. But even after the presence of children, those two are not and cannot be husband and wife.
So, as they live in a permanent sinful condition, they cannot receive Holy Communion.
But they cannot even confess, if they want to continue that irregular situation.
They can receive the sacraments only if his wife dies and they regularize their situation, or in extremis at the end of their life, to prepare to enter Paradise.
That is true here, in America and everywhere in the world as well.
5. What can be done concretely to get out of that situation?
Since the new union shows a certain character of stability and there is a duty to stay together because they are the parents of two children, one could examine whether there is any element in his religious marriage which would void it.
But it is necessary to meet an ecclesiastical judge who, even after a brief conversation, can notice elements to proceed for a decree of nullity.
In the positive case, once the nullity of the marriage is decreed, the two will be able to confess, communicate and celebrate their sacramental wedding.
6. In the meantime, pending that sentence or after a negative sentence, they cannot celebrate the religious wedding; the only way to receive sacraments is to not behave as husband and wife, i.e., along the path of sexual abstinence.
In this case, however, they will be able to receive the sacraments where they are not known as divorced and remarried in order not to generate confusion and even scandal among the other faithful.
I greet and I bless you.
Father Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

