Most Reverend Father,

I write you to ask for your authoritative opinion on the following questions regarding the sacrament of Confession:

1) whether it is possible, in case of adultery, to absolve the repentant penitent without requiring, as a necessary condition for absolution, to confess the betrayal to the unaware spouse and ask him or her for forgiveness;

2) whether a penitent who only confesses the sin of adultery and does not also confess the sin of lying with the intent to deceive (a sin that is independent of but always goes along with adultery) and receives absolution, is then allowed to partake of the Eucharist;

3) whether a penitent who admits both the primary sin of adultery and the accessory sin of lying can be absolved without the confessor requiring him or her to at least make amends for the lies and deceptions (since it is not possible to make amends for the adultery as well) by truthfully describing the events to the innocent spouse.

Hoping for your kind answer, I send you my respectful regards.

Egidio


Priest’s answer

Dear Egidio,

1. the priest is not required to prescribe, as a necessary condition for sacramental absolution, the disclosure of the unfaithfulness to the spouse.

If the unfaithfulness, even if not known, has seriously damaged the marriage, the disclosure of that unfaithfulness could indeed destroy it. Or, in any case, it could create an atmosphere of ongoing suspicion and permanently undermine serenity.

The priest must therefore act with utmost caution.

2. It is true that in concealing an unfaithfulness it is fatal to cover it up with many lies. And this is why, I believe, St. Thomas says that among the effects of lust are duplicity and lying.

However, without resorting to lying, one can apply a mental restriction.

A mental restriction is also this: “I assure you that there has been no unfaithfulness,” implying “that I am obliged to disclose to you.” That is done exactly for the greater good of the marriage and the family.

3. In general, the penitent is absolved both of the sin of adultery and of any lies with which he or she may have covered it up.

As I have already said, disclosing what happened could be disastrous for the stability of the family and especially for the children.

But if instead of telling lies one applies a mental restriction, it is not a lie, and there is no reason in itself to admit it as such.

4. Those are general criteria of caution.

That does not mean that there are no cases where it is necessary to disclose what one did, especially when the incident is well-known and it is urgent to take the right steps to try and make amends—as far as possible—for serious consequences involving individuals and the family itself.

I bless you and remember you in prayer,

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian