Hello Father Angelo,

Excuse me again if I inconvenience you, but I have some important questions to ask you as I can’t find an answer to them:

1. In the last few days I have often heard about glorifying God in weakness, because it is there that he shows his strength. However, as I think about that, I feel like some kind of puppet created just to be free to glorify God, as it is the only way in which I can find my own happiness. As if God would little by little lead me to understand that that is the only way, thus cornering me and leaving me with no way out. However, such freedom would be a fake one.

2. The second question is about all my qualities having been bestowed on me only to fulfill God’s plan for me. In the end, it is always only about him and our freedom is fake.

3. I feel that God loves me, but I also feel that when a Father loves, how could he fail to fulfill the deepest desires of our hearts. For example, a little girl who is born paralyzed and perhaps in the depths of her heart has the desire to walk, see the world, get to know her own man… How could a God who claims to love us not fulfill for everyone, without showing preference (because, apparently, some people are listened to and others are not), the deepest desires of our hearts. How does a person who has certain kinds of disease understand that this cross is love, honestly, I would get very angry with anyone who would tell me something like that. Wouldn’t it be enough for God to lovingly explain such things, like my father consoles me when I’m sad?

4. How come he allows certain nightmarish, rare, mental, and other horrible diseases to exist, which Jesus never experienced in his body and in his mind. How is he entitled to say to these people as well, take up your cross, without having experienced certain kinds of crosses?

Thank you,

Nicola


Answer from the priest

Dear Nicola,

1. Yes, we were created for the glory of God.

But not to be puppets in the hands of someone else, as if he needed our help to increase his happiness.

But rather to take possession of the glory of God, that is to say, of that which is essential to God.

2. Our relationship with God finds many similarities with that between the ray of light and the light source.

The ray is nothing by itself, if the light source does not feed it.

It has nothing to communicate except light itself.

If it wanted to do anything without the light source, it would immediately bring about its own destruction.

It is a grace for it that the light source created it, that it enlivens it moment by moment and gives it all the splendor and beauty with which it is clothed.

So it is for us: it is a grace to have been created, to be able to partake in God’s life and make something together with him that will last forever.

Without him, not only can we do nothing, but we would immediately fall into the void from which we were drawn.

3. We are called to partake in the life and power of God all the time, even in moments when we experience weakness and suffering.

It is in relation to this that St. Paul tells us to glorify God in our weaknesses: “Therefore, I am content with weaknesses, insults, hardships, persecutions, and constraints, for the sake of Christ; for when I am weak, then I am strong” (2 Cor 12:10).

He states this in reference to a thorn in the flesh, to an angel of Satan who beat him, for which he had three times asked the Lord to be delivered. But three times the Lord had answered him: “My grace is sufficient for you” (2 Cor 12:7).

4. Reassured by these words of the Lord, Paul knows that his sufferings joined with those of Christ produce harvest even more abundant than that delivered by preaching.

In his suffering joined with that of Jesus Christ crucified there is an extraordinary conquering power. The power in relation to which the Lord had said: “And when I am lifted up from the earth, I will draw everyone to myself” (Jn 12:32).

5. If by freedom you mean being able to do something without God and outside God’s plan, by that you do not produce anything that will last eternally.

It would be a freedom given to death, because if one does not build in God, that is, in his grace, everything is inexorably devoured by time and by nothingness.

So, we can conclude with the Ecclesiastes: “vanity of vanities! All things are vanity!” (Ecclesiastes 1:2), everything is useless.

6. You further write about “all my qualities having been bestowed on me only to fulfill God’s plan for me. In the end, it is always only about him and our freedom is fake.”

What are your qualities if not those that God bestowed on you?

Furthermore, God’s plan is not something detached from you, as if you had to become alienated from yourself to achieve it.

Instead, it is the one you find written in your most intimate foundation.

Achieving does not bring about your alienation, but your perfect happiness.

Because it is with all your strength, all your energy that you yearn for that.

This is why I have already told you previously that one’s vocation is what one is, it is what one is “made for”, “cut for”.

7. Then there is a problem that worries you: if the Lord loves you and loves you with an omnipotent love, why does he not fulfill your deepest desires?

Again: your deepest desires are those that he aroused in your heart because “God is the one who, for his good purpose, works in you both to desire and to work” (Phil 2:13).

Why then does he not fulfill the desire to be healed in a paralyzed child?

Now it is necessary to remember that God did not create us simply for earthly life. It would be an insult to create us and then make us die forever.

Instead, he created us for eternal life.

Within our present life we are called to prepare for a great future life.

It is only in this perspective that we can understand anything.

Is not this the meaning of the beatitude proclaimed by the Lord in his first great speech: “Blessed are they who mourn, for they will be comforted” (Mt 5:4)?

Outside of this light, nothing can be understood. There is only darkness.

Atheists reject this light. But they do not have another one. They face only that pitch-black darkness and a meaningless life.

8. Now I am thinking of the great character of the last canonized Dominican saint: Margaret of Città di Castello.

She was born crippled and blind (what can be worse than that?) and she was left on the street by her parents.

But she managed to take advantage of her condition to receive the true light in her own mind.

She was able to bestow that light of hers on many people who resorted to her, who had the light of the eyes but not the inner light.

9. Finally, you talk about diseases that Jesus did not experience.

St. Thomas puts forth the question of whether Christ suffered all forms of suffering.

He answers by making a distinction between specific suffering and general suffering.

If we consider suffering of each individual kind, Jesus Christ did not suffer them all, also because “many are mutually exclusive, as burning and drowning”.

Among other things, the Gospel notes that the two thieves had their legs broken. Jesus did not suffer this particular form of suffering.

10. “But, speaking generically, He did endure every human suffering. This admits of a threefold acceptance.

First of all, on the part of men: for He endured something from Gentiles and from Jews; from men and from women, as is clear from the women servants who accused Peter. He suffered from the rulers, from their servants and from the mob, according to Psalm 2:1-2: ‘Why have the Gentiles raged, and the people devised vain things? The kings of the earth stood up, and the princes met together, against the Lord and against His Christ.’ He suffered from friends and acquaintances, as is manifest from Judas betraying and Peter denying Him.

Secondly, the same is evident on the part of the sufferings which a man can endure. For Christ suffered from friends abandoning Him; in His reputation, from the blasphemies hurled at Him; in His honor and glory, from the mockeries and the insults heaped upon Him; in things, for He was despoiled of His garments; in His soul, from sadness, weariness, and fear; in His body, from wounds and scourgings.

Thirdly, it may be considered with regard to His bodily members. In His head He suffered from the crown of piercing thorns; in His hands and feet, from the fastening of the nails; on His face from the blows and spittle; and from the lashes over His entire body. Moreover, He suffered in all His bodily senses: in touch, by being scourged and nailed; in taste, by being given vinegar and gall to drink; in smell, by being fastened to the gibbet in a place reeking with the stench of corpses, ‘which is called Calvary’; in hearing, by being tormented with the cries of blasphemers and scorners; in sight, by beholding the tears of His Mother and of the disciple whom He loved.” (Summa theologiae, III, 46, 5).

Not to mention the pains of the soul that weighed on Jesus from the first moment of his existence because of his sharing in the pains of all mankind (“Who is weak, and I am not weak?”, 2 Cor 11:29) which he saw one by one.

11. Yes, before telling all people to take up their cross and follow him, Jesus already had them all individually present in his soul.

Only by divine intervention did these sufferings not crush the body of Jesus, because otherwise he could not have fulfilled his ministry.

I bless you, I wish you well, and I remember you in prayer.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish Portuguese