Dear Father Angelo,

what does it mean to witness the faith?

Let me explain better: how should we behave in order to be witnesses of faith without shame, but also without ostentation, fanaticism and even risk of ridiculing the faith itself? How to discern the most appropriate moments and those less appropriate without hiding behind the “virtue of Prudence” that is in reality fear or shame (which are instead sins)?

I believe, tell me if I am wrong, that the first testimony, essential, to which we are called is that of life: not to express oneself in certain ways (blasphemies, profanity, oaths, naming in vain the name of God or Our Lady), dress modestly, do small acts of charity not for your own gain but for the love of God, avoid murmuring and slander and try to nip in group conversations (…).

There is also the testimony of the word: to say things as they are when we are questioned (questions like “what do you think about abortion?”, “why do you want to bet a virgin until marriage, what’s the point?”, “why do you believe?”), to tell someone that blasphemy annoys and to the question “why, are you a believer?” to answer calmly with a convinced yes, etc. (…).

I am little trained about the testimony with external gestures, such as the sign of the cross before meals or in front of a church, kissing a medal or a Rosary in front of many people, holding in hand a small dozen of the Rosary in front of all, kneeling to receive Holy Communion while in line, etc.

I believe I have false beliefs about this.

I know that these positive precepts always oblige, but not at all times. But how can I understand when it is time?

These gestures are beautiful in themselves, but they leave me perplexed: making them in a visible way seems to me almost a forcing and an ostentation, not making them publicly leaves me embittered and upset, because Jesus has expressly said “Who will be ashamed of me and my words, in the midst of this adulterous and sinful generation, even the Son of man will be ashamed of him when he comes in the glory of his Father, with holy angels.” “Whoever will recognize me before men, I too will recognize him before my Father in heaven; but whoever denies me before men, I too will deny him before my Father in heaven” (…).

What is the point of praying as much as possible even in the “dead times” of the day if you do not have the courage to show a very small dozen of the Rosary in hand? One wonders how much faith is worth at this point.

I could give many examples of this kind, where changing behavior according to how many and which people there are and according to the context seems something wise perhaps, but also shameful (…).

Personally, I have noticed that often, when I pray on the street or in public transport, the  less  I show the more I can concentrate (but at the same time I regret not having witnessed the faith with gestures), while if I impose to “give testimony” making some gesture in front of everyone, I lose my inner life and almost expose myself to the temptation of vanity or at least those gestures become empty, forced, subject to greater distractions, almost harmful, and I also do not like this, but at least I have the awareness that I have done everything I had to do (or at least in my head it seems so, although I am not really sure).

Sometimes hiding favors intimacy with God and humility, yet at the same time, just that hiding seems also a reason for condemnation or in any case an offense to God, perhaps not serious, but still a deliberate offense.

1. Since it is not possible that it is wrong doing and not doing something at the same time, I hope you can give me an answer and, if you consider it useful to publish it, give to all those who have my same doubts some indications about the testimony with external gestures.

2. I also ask you, possibly, the courtesy to draw a line between mild and severe matter in this field, so that even in case of fall there is not always the anguish of guilt, but only in really serious cases, asking God for forgiveness in the mild cases and humbly accepting one’s own fragility without losing peace.

Thank you for your very useful service, indeed.

Since my adolescence it has been very precious to me to focus always on our goal as baptized, that is the sanctification, coming into contact with reality that at catechism I had never known and with which, for the time in which I was born, I have never come into contact.

I am sure that God greatly appreciates your work.

The words of the Prophet Isaiah apply to you too: “The ancient ruins shall be rebuilt for your sake, and the foundations from ages past you shall raise up; “Repairer of the breach,” they shall call you, “Restorer of ruined homesteads” (Is 58,12).”

As soon as I send this question I will pray with the Holy Rosary and right now I will remember yoy in prayer.

Cordially, D.

Answer of the priest

Dear D.,

1. I note with satisfaction that you know how to make many appropriate distinctions about the question you have asked me.

I come immediately to answer your question: “what does it mean to witness the faith” or even: what to do to witness the faith.

You rightly say that the first witness is made with life. And you exemplify this testimony in many concrete acts.

However, the first testimony, preceding that of the acts mentioned, is that which is made by being united to the Lord through grace.

Just next Sunday (sixth Sunday of Easter, year a) we will hear from Saint Peter as you make testimony to Christ.

These are his words which, being inspired by the Holy Spirit are words of God: “Sanctify Christ as Lord in your hearts. Always be ready to give an explanation to anyone who asks you for a reason for your hope, but do it with gentleness and reverence, keeping your conscience clear, so that, when you are maligned, those who defame your good conduct in Christ may themselves be put to shame”  (1 Pt 3,15-16).

2. The first witness is that which one gives with one’s own conduct by living in God’s grace: “Sanctify Christ as Lord in your hearts”.

It is necessary that within our heart there be personally present Jesus, who in the Revelation defines himself as “the bright morning star” (Rev 22:16).

If this light is present, without any ostentation, a certain luminosity that refers to Christ shines out of us.

It is a light that infects, that leaves a sense of well-being and peace in the people who are next to it.

Therefore, the first thing to do is to worship Christ in our hearts, to make him present secretly through our state of grace.

If you are not in grace, you can do many good works, you can speak well of Jesus Christ, but being as branches detached from the vine,  you do not bring any fruit.

Jesus has said: “Remain in me, as I remain in you. Just as a branch cannot bear fruit on its own unless it remains on the vine, so neither can you unless you remain in me. I am the vine, you are the branches. Whoever remains in me and I in him will bear much fruit, because without me you can do nothing” (Jn 15,4-5).

It is the basic principle of Christian witness that it should not be taken for granted. If we do not remain in Christ and if Christ does not dwell in us through grace, our witness can communicate something beautiful and attractive from the external point of view, but it does not make Christ present and does not allow his life-giving power to touch hearts.

3. Secondly, as the Holy Spirit says through the mouth of Peter, it is necessary to know how to answer anyone who asks us reason for the hope that is in us. This means that you need to be prepared from a doctrinal point of view.

It is understandable and reasonable that others, seeing our behavior, ask questions and expect convincing answers.

It is not necessary to go far to find the answer because “All scripture is inspired by God and is useful for teaching, for refutation, for correction, and for training in righteousness” (2 Tim 3:16).

Therefore our witness must be prepared through catechesis and permanent formation.

4. Next, Saint Peter says how the evangelical doctrine should be explained: “responding to anyone“, without making distinctions because we must bring the salvation of Christ to all.

In addition, our exposure must exclude aggression and arrogance. It must be done “with sweetness”, making manifest the lovability of Christ, of his doctrine and Christian life.

Even if some people show bitterness towards us, towards the faith we profess and towards that which is religious, nevertheless we must make the meekness of Christ shine before all. Did not Jesus Christ say: “I am sending you like lambs among wolves”? (Lk 10,3).

Meekness disarms the arrogant and has the strength to bring him back to himself, to be more reflective and reasonable.

It must be done with respect to each person. Respect is the minimum measure of our love for all.

5. It is true that Jesus said: “Everyone who acknowledges me before others I will acknowledge before my heavenly Father. But whoever denies me before others, I will deny before my heavenly Father” (Mt 10:32).

But it is necessary to be cautious as snakes, as the Lord has taught us, to assess whether our testimony is necessary, if it can be understood in order not to be counterproductive.

It is right, therefore, to remember that the positive precepts always oblige, but not at all times. While the negative precepts, which in our case are those that prohibit to deny Jesus Christ, oblige always and in all circumstances.

Sometimes, in particularly critical situations where any solution could be misunderstood, one can invoke the right not to answer before others of our religious belief. Because the right to religious freedom must be guaranteed for all.

6. Without going into the casuistry in which you would like to take me at the end of your mail, I limit myself to recall in general terms that we have two resources to understand if our testimony can be appropriate.

The first is common sense, which on the one hand excludes ostentation. Ostentation annoys, it can be provocative. In any case, it is counterproductive.

In this regard it should be remembered that a certain modesty is also required in spiritual things, especially when they are out of place and cannot be understood.

7. The second resource that we have at our disposal, if we live in grace, is the gift of counsel, which is a particular gift of the Holy Spirit that helps to find a prompt and fruitful solution to individual problems.

I remember reading the testimony of Lucia of Fatima who, being in a serious difficulty of choice, and indeed having beheld the wrong choice because it seemed better to her, felt that Francis, smaller than her, illuminated by the Holy Spirit found the solution. It was a satisfactory solution for all.

The Holy Spirit, especially if invoked, comes to the rescue.

8. Thank you for what you wrote to me at the end of your email.

How I would like to be up to what God asks us through the prophet Isaiah.

And yet allow me to say that it would be so beautiful if you were for all “Repairer of the breach,” they shall call you, “Restorer of ruined homesteads” (Is 58:12).

I see the qualities.

I am sorry that I had to make some cuts to your mail because, although very nice, it would have been too long.

9. I wish you to be a witness of Christ, before even speaking or doing certain actions.

By worshiping Christ in your heart and cultivating the spiritual life, it will be easy for everyone to grasp in you that something different, which there is not in others, and which in biblical and theological terms is called grace.

For this I bless you and gladly accompany you with prayer.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish Portuguese