Dear Father Angelo,
What is meant by partial or imperfect consent (which is supposed to turn a mortal sin into a venial one)?
In the case of impure thoughts, for example, how can one tell whether one has given full or partial consent to them?
Thanking you for all you do, I would like to take this opportunity to wish you a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.
Daniele
Priest’s answer
Dear Daniele,
1. deliberate consent constitutes a voluntary act.
In this regard, with reference to sin – since this is the subject of your enquiry – theologians make a number of distinctions.
2. First of all, they speak of full voluntariness when there is an awareness of the gravity of the action and a decision is made to carry it out.
Sin is grave from the very moment one decides to carry out a particular action.
In this sense, Jesus said that ‘anyone who looks at a woman and lusts after her (that is, intends to seduce her) has already committed adultery with her in his heart’ (Mt 5:28).
It is true that the external sin adds further gravity, because having to overcome obstacles further confirms one’s inclination towards evil. But the act is already perverse in its psychological formulation.
3. Similarly, a sin can be grave at the very stage of decision-making in other areas, such as when a theft is planned down to the last detail to ensure its success.
It is already a grave sin even before any action is taken.
The same applies to premeditated murder, even if it is not carried out. There was a deliberate intention to kill.
4. Sometimes, however, one does not actually decide to commit any impure act. One merely views pornography.
It is true that viewing is also an act, and it’s an impure one, but in itself it does not lead to an inappropriate use of one’s reproductive capacity, even though the link is almost always very close. This viewing is already a depravity of another person’s body, reduced to an object of filthy desires, and even more so it is a depravity and corruption of one’s own emotional life, which remains deeply wounded and polluted.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church speaks unequivocally of ‘grave sin’ (CCC 2354).
So far, there are no problems; everything is clear.
5. Sometimes, however, thoughts, imaginings or sensations arise of their own accord, and we find ourselves passive in the face of them.
This is probably not just a matter of ‘sometimes’, but of ‘most of the time’.
Well, if we do not consent to them, they remain at the level of temptation.
These are acts or impulses that moralists call ‘primo-primi’, in that they occur (or are experienced) before any deliberation and are entirely involuntary. According to St Thomas, these impulses are in no way sinful (cf. Commentary on the Sentences, II, d. 24, q. 3,2)
6. In practice, however, these thoughts or inner stirrings can be persistent, leaving one feeling almost under siege.
When they are rejected with one’s whole being, they can provide an opportunity for merit.
To Saint Catherine of Siena, demons would sometimes appear in obscene forms and would not leave her. However humiliating and painful such a struggle was for her, not only was there no fault or wound, but victory and merit.
Demons do not appear to ordinary mortals. But sometimes they are immersed in an atmosphere steeped in sensuality.
Those who strive for holiness realise that this atmosphere, which touches our soul, does not promote intimate communion with God, yet neither does it destroy it.
Nevertheless, whilst not being a grave sin, it is constantly brought up in confession so that we may become aware of the extent of our reaction and be better prepared for the battles to come.
They are the subject of constant accusation when it comes to confessions of venial sins alone.
7. In this regard, St Thomas writes: ‘The will has complete dominion over certain things, but incomplete dominion over others.
It has complete dominion over those acts which proceed from the command of the will; these are the acts that follow deliberation and are attributed to reason.
It has, however, incomplete dominion over those acts which do not proceed from the command of reason, but which the will could nevertheless have prevented, so that they are in a certain sense subject to the will insofar as they can be prevented or not prevented: thus the disorder occurring in these acts gives rise to the character of sin, yet it is incomplete; therefore, in these acts, the sin is very slight and venial, not mortal, which is perfect sin” (Ib.).
To these acts, movements or sensations that are not fully deliberate and imputable, which are called ‘secundo primi’, are also attributed to those of the half-awake state.
In return for your kind wishes for a happy Christmas and New Year (2024), I send you my blessings and keep you in my prayers.
Father Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

