Dear Father,
Matthew reported the parable of the laborers in the vineyard and I would ask you to explain some of its aspects that are obscure to me.
The owner of the vineyard (God) decides to give all the laborers (the men who work for His Kingdom) the same coin (eternal life) even if some workers have worked much less than others.
I caught this: God is good and merciful, He wants to save everyone, He gives salvation to anyone who converts and decides to follow Him, no matter when, even at the end of life.
First doubt: whether the last-hour laborer deserves a place in heaven too, I wonder about those who demonstrated coherence, perseverance, and Christian perfection throughout their life (not my case, but for example that of religious people, elected by God, who renounced everything for God), if they deserve enjoying a particular privilege among the blessed souls. In this sense, they would be repaid by a coin that would not be the same as the one given to the last-hour worker, and in my opinion that seems corresponding to God’s justice.
Second doubt: why were last-hour laborers paid before the ones who worked since the morning? as last, why did they become first? Why did they receive by God, besides the same wage (as God’s mercy demands), also the privilege of being paid first (while justice would ask the contrary)?
I read in the Gospel commented by Marco Sales that God, in giving the final reward, looks only at the amount of grace that each soul is clothed with, adding that God is the master of His grace and distributes it to whom He wants and as He wants.
In my opinion, eternal life is a gift that God gives to whom He wants (if man accepts it, of course) and that merit counts for little because, ultimately, one can never merit for the good deeds, since they depend on God Himself Who makes them performed. Does it appear a bit unfair to you? What about human commitment? Suffering? Renunciation? Before God, any good deed of ours does not appear to really matter, as He decides whether to give a kilo of grace or a ton, and having more, and even doing less, one can skip the queue and collect the prize first.
I cordially greet you and thank you.
Michael
The Priest’s answer
Dear Michael,
1. as justice governs relationships between people, likewise one can appropriately speak of injustice.
But one cannot speak of injustice in the order of grace, because everything is grace.
In Christian life, one has no merit in having been called since the first hour.
That is grace too.
Even becoming a great saint is grace.
Everything is grace, said St. Teresa of the Child Jesus.
2. Furthermore, we should note that the Lord expresses a parable, so the speech is sometimes hyperbolic.
3. We should remember the deeper meaning of the parable which concerns the pagans who received the announcement of salvation only later.
The Jews had no merit in having been the chosen people and having received the revelation first.
4. St. Thomas, commenting on this Gospel passage (Mt 20:1-15), says that, when entering eternal life, each one receives something equal and something unequal.
That is because all receive the beatitude of paradise, and this is equally participated. The last ones become first, and that is, equal to the first ones, as St. John Chrysostom says.
But each one participates in a greater way than another.
Here are his exact words: “I say that there will be an equal repayment in a certain respect, but in a certain respect not. For beatitude can be considered as regards the object, and in this way there is one beatitude for all; or it can be considered as regards participation in the object, and in this way not all will participate equally, because they will not see thus clearly; in my Father’s house there are many mansions (John 14:2). And it is as if many men go to water, and one carries more than another: the river puts forth its whole self, yet not all carry equally. In this way, he who has a soul more enlarged with charity will accept more.”
5. To those who grumbled because they had endured the day’s burden and the heat, “My friend, I am not cheating you”, St. Thomas writes: “I give him what is mine, not what is yours, so I am not cheating you.”
6. In fact, keeping the scope of participation, St. Paul will say that glory can variously manifest in heaven for those who enjoy the resurrection of the flesh and the vision of God: “The brightness of the sun is one kind, the brightness of the moon another, and the brightness of the stars another. For star differs from star in brightness.” (1Cor 15:41).
7. Finally, theologians add a further distinction between essential glory and accidental one.
Beatitude (essential glory) is identical for all, and yet each one participates in it according to his own greatness of charity; besides it, there is accidental glory that consists in the enjoyment of many other goods that are not identified within the beatific vision of God.
Therefore, in heaven there is eternal mercy for all but also just retribution according to merits.
I bless you, wishing I will see you among the highest saints in heaven.
Father Angelo

