Good morning, Father,

but negative moral precepts depend on the times and people’s mentality, right?

That is, there may be historical periods and populations where not all negative moral precepts apply to them, right?

And so some of them depend on circumstances…

What do you think?

Thank you.


Priest’s answer

Dear friend,

1.negative moral precepts, that is, those that forbid doing evil, transcend time and human mentality.

2.In Veritatis splendor, by John Paul II, we read: “In the case of the positive moral precepts, prudence always has the task of verifying that they apply in a specific situation, for example, in view of other duties which may be more important or urgent. But the negative moral precepts, those prohibiting certain concrete actions or kinds of behaviour as intrinsically evil, do not allow for any legitimate exception. They do not leave room, in any morally acceptable way, for the “creativity” of any contrary determination whatsoever. Once the moral species of an action prohibited by a universal rule is concretely recognized, the only morally good act is that of obeying the moral law and of refraining from the action which it forbids.” (VS 67).

3.And, refuting the thinking of some who, in view of certain circumstances, say that transgressing in that case would be the only possible good, he reiterates that “such theories however are not faithful to the Church’s teaching, when they believe they can justify, as morally good, deliberate choices of kinds of behaviour contrary to the commandments of the divine and natural law. 

These theories cannot claim to be grounded in the Catholic moral tradition. Although the latter did witness the development of a casuistry which tried to assess the best ways to achieve the good in certain concrete situations, it is nonetheless true that this casuistry concerned only cases in which the law was uncertain, and thus the absolute validity of negative moral precepts, which oblige without exception, was not called into question. The faithful are obliged to acknowledge and respect the specific moral precepts declared and taught by the Church in the name of God, the Creator and Lord. (VS 76).

4.“The negative precepts of the natural law are universally valid: they oblige each and every individual, always and in every circumstance.

It is a matter of prohibitions which forbid a given action semper et pro semper, without exception, because the choice of this kind of behaviour is in no case compatible with the goodness of the will of the acting person, with his vocation to life with God and to communion with his neighbour. It is prohibited — to everyone and in every case — to violate these precepts. They oblige everyone, regardless of the cost, never to offend anyone, beginning with oneself, the personal dignity common to all.” (VS 52).

‘The Church’s firmness in defending the universal and unchanging moral norms is not demeaning at all…. When it is a matter of the moral norms prohibiting intrinsic evil, there are no privileges or exceptions for anyone. It makes no difference whether one is the master of the world or the “poorest of the poor” on the face of the earth. Before the demands of morality we are all absolutely equal.” (VS 96).

5.The case of negative disciplinary precepts is different.

The Church’s legislation provides for disciplinary precepts that command or prohibit.

Examples of positive disciplinary precepts are holy days of obligation.

The Church itself dispenses with the precept when these feasts do not coincide with Sunday, such as the feast of St Joseph, St Peter and St Paul, Corpus Christi and the Ascension.

The Church even provides for an exemption from negative disciplinary precepts if they are too burdensome in the name of the principle lex positiva (here positive means disciplinary) non obligat cum nimio incommodo (“positive laws do not oblige with grave inconvenience”).

Therefore, the law prohibiting lay people from entering cloistered places is not binding when such a violation is required in the name of charity, as in the case of medical assistance to a sick person.

6.In your email, you were probably referring to these precepts.

However, one cannot fail to note the clarity of the teachings of Saint Pope John Paul II.

Perhaps no one would have thought that his teachings would become so prophetic, so illuminating.

His teaching reveals once again God’s merciful gift to us who live in this moment.

I bless you, wish you all the best, and remember you in my prayers.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian