Dear Reverend Father Angelo Bellon.
1. I wanted to ask you a question regarding the topic of Mary’s impeccability and free will.
I read in Casali’s Compendium of Dogmatic Theology that: “Most theologians believe that Mary had the privilege of impeccability, not intrinsically like Jesus by her nature, but extrinsically and morally, that is, by the grace given to her by God for her divine Maternity, she could not sin, without however being deprived of freedom and therefore of merit.”
If Mary could not sin, her free will was not capable of sinning, then she deduces that she could not say no to the Angel during the Annunciation. So how can we talk about merit in this case?
Couldn’t God also give the gift of impeccability to Adam and Eve so as not to lose, for them or for their descendants, their original justice and holiness without pain, disease, or death, and so as not to take away free will and merit from their ancestors?
I thought that free will and impeccability were exclusive gifts between them: that impeccability excluded free will, merit, and vice versa.
Our progenitors with free will stand out and are superior to animals. With impeccability they would also have had exemption from so many evils.
Is it of great praise to Mary for having been a Saint for the gift of impeccability and not for having freely chosen good with her free will, being able in theory to also choose evil?
2. I would like to ask you if Mary, free from original sin, had also received all the preternatural gifts that our ancestors received before the fall.
I am referring to gifts such as exemption from death, disease, ignorance, pain, infirmities of the body, infused science.
Thank you in advance for your reply.
I will be happy to remember you in my prayers.
Kind regards. Thank you in advance for your reply.
Marchesini
Response from the priest
Dear Marchesini,
1. What Casali said is true.
In Mary’s case, it is about extrinsic and moral impeccability, that is: she was given such a high degree of holiness that it would have been surprising to see Mary commit a sin, since all her attraction was towards God.
Such impeccability is not opposed to freedom.
By preserving freedom, she also preserved merit.
2. God allowed Adam’s sin with a view to a greater good.
And we already see this good in Mary who becomes her Mother precisely because of the incarnation of God.
3. God gave Adam superabundant grace not to sin.
Of course God could also have created a world with all very holy people like Our Lady.
But this one he did not do. And if he didn’t, he must have had his reasons, which we will see in the times.
But when we see them we will not be able to fail to say with the inhabitants of heaven: “True and just are your judgments!” (Rev 15:7)
4. About the second question: Jesus was also free from original sin, but he did not want to be free from our infirmities. This was also the case by divine decree for Mary.
5. Infused science is a gift distinct from the preternatural gifts of immunity from death and pain.
Many saints, while not enjoying immunity from pain and death, have had
infused science.
But before them and more than them, Jesus had the most perfect knowledge, even though he was subject of his own will to pain and death.
Maria too (we can’t doubt it!) had infused science. So many saints have had it. How can we not admit it into Her who is the mother, certainly subordinate to Christ, of all holiness?
I thank you for the memory of me in your prayers.
I reciprocate heartily and bless you. Father Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

