Question

Dear Father Angelo,

I’m A…and I’m 30 years of age.

I was born and raised in a Neocatechumenal family, the eldest of 6 children, and I too began the Way at the age of 13,  which  I then abandoned for theological and liturgical reasons.

I am writing to ask you two questions regarding the theology of the Way about the Holy Mass.

1 – Still today, during the “convivence of birth”, a long catechesis about the Eucharist states that it is right to consider it only as a Sacrifice, but it is incomplete as the Mass  makes present the entire Paschal Mystery (which also includes the Resurrection), hence it must be defined as a “Sacrifice of praise”.

Now I ask myself: is it possible to reconcile these statements with the decrees of the Council of Trent, according to which the Holy Mass is not only a sacrifice of praise and thanksgiving but also an expiatory and propitiatory one?

Furthermore, is it true that the Holy Mass also presents the Resurrection of Christ and not just the Sacrifice of the Calvary? Has the Church ever stated anything  in this regard?

If I am not mistaken, according to the classical – Thomistic – dogmatic theology, the Resurrection would be the fruit of the Sacrifice (we feed on the risen and glorious Christ, in Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity during Communion, and not on His “Corpse”) but the Mass presents in a bloodless way the Sacrifice alone, mystically represented by the separation of Species, and not  the Resurrection, which took place once and for all.

Therefore, I wonder if the Neocatechumenal catechesis is placed on the path of the Apostolic Tradition (in a context of reform in continuity) or if it has a doctrinal imperfection.

2 – The second question concerns the Offertory, which is practically absent from the Neocatechumenal Liturgies, as the Priest anticipates  the correspondent prayers in  the Missal during the exchange of Peace (usually accompanied by a non-offertory hymn), thanks to an indult granted by the Holy See in 1988.

The main liturgist, who inspired the practice of the Way, is Archbishop Pedro Farnès (who died last year if I remember correctly); he explained a few years ago in an essay of his (“Vivere l’Eucaristia che il Signore ci ha comandato di celebrare”, tr.: “Living the Eucharist that the Lord has commanded us to celebrate”) that the Offering of Christ to the Father and of the Church, His Mystical Body, with Him, takes place only AFTER the Consecration, precisely at the words “we offer you, Father, this life-giving bread, this saving cup”, and it would be consequently meaningless to anticipate or split  it within the Offertory which, therefore, should not be defined as such, since it is a mere “preparation of what is needed” to celebrate the Eucharist, not deserving any emphasis, ….

My question: is this statement correct?

Thank you in advance for your reply and, please, remember me and my family in the Holy Mass( together with my wife G…. and to our eldest son T….)


Answer from the priest

Dear Andrea,

1. The Mass is the memorial of the Lord’s Passion.

St. Paul clearly affirms that saying: “For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the death of the Lord until he comes.” (1Cor 11:26).

However, we can only celebrate the Passion memorial because the Lord is risen and lives with us.

2. In the Mass, the risen and glorious Lord is the one who approaches us to make the sacrifice of His passion and His death present on our altars.

If Christ had not risen, we would be only able to celebrate  the memory of His Passion.

3. The memorial is not simply a memory, but makes present and alive what we remember.

Memory is pure remembrance.

Adding to remembering, the memorial is – also and above all – making the event of the Lord’s Passion and death really present and alive to us.

And it also existentially signs us through the celebrated event.

4. The Mass is “in order to perpetuate the sacrifice of the Cross throughout the centuries” (Vatican Council II, Sacrosanctum Concilium, 47).

The Christian people rightly say to the priest’s proclamation of the “mystery of faith”: “We announce your death, Lord!”.

5. This atonement sacrifice was accepted by the Father and He testified that through Christ’s Resurrection from the dead.

Therefore “The Eucharistic Sacrifice makes present not only the mystery of our Savior’s Passion and death, but also the mystery of His Resurrection which crowned His sacrifice. It is through the living and risen One that Christ can become  the “bread of life” (Jn 6:35, 48), the “living bread” in the Eucharistic (Jn 6:51)” (John Paul II, Ecclesia de Eucharistia, 14).

6. You say that the Resurrection of Christ is the fruit of the Sacrifice of the cross.

John Paul II says it is His crowning glory. But the two expressions are equivalent.

The Resurrection of Christ is decisive for being able to celebrate the memorial.

You rightly write that “we feed on the risen and glorious Christ, in Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity during Communion, and not on his ‘corpse’)”.

And I emphasize: of the risen Christ Who makes present His Passion and death on the altar for our benefit.

In the Apocalypse Saint John sees Jesus standing in Heaven as a slain Lamb (rf. Rev 5:6).

He sees Him standing. And that is the sign of His Resurrection.

And it is only because He is risen that He can make His Passion and death eternal and make that contemporary to us.

7. Defining the Eucharist as a sacrifice of praise (sacrificium laudis) is correct.

Eucharist means thanksgiving or even praise.

In Hebrew ‘praise’ and ‘thank’ are said with the same word: todah.

We also find this expression of sacrificium laudis in the Roman Canon: “Memento, Domine, famulorum famularumque tuarum et omnium circumstantium, quorum tibi fides cognita est et nota devotio, pro quibus tibi offerimus: vel qui tibi offerunt hoc sacrificium laudis, pro se suisque omnibus” (Remember, Lord, your faithful. Remember all those present, whose faith and devotion you know: we also offer you for them they offer you this sacrifice of praise, they raise the prayer to you, the eternal, living and true, to obtain redemption, safety of life and health for themselves and their loved ones).

8. Therefore, the neocatechumenal catechesis remains in the line of tradition, while accentuating the aspect of the Lord’s resurrection.

It should also be equally remembered that the Lord is risen to make Himself present on our altars in the event of His passion and His death.

9. Regarding the second question: the offertory is the moment of preparation or presentation of the offer.

Our offering, together with that of Christ, is made with the consecration and is explicitly expressed after the consecration.

10. Here is what St. Thomas says: “In regard to the oblation, two things are done, namely, the people’s praise in singing the “offertory,” expressing the joy of the offerors, and the priest’s prayer asking for the people’s oblation to be made acceptable to God. Hence David said (1 Para 29:17): “In the simplicity of my heart, I have . . . offered all these things: and I have seen with great joy Thy people which are here present, offer Thee their offerings”: and then he makes the following prayer: “O Lord God . . . keep . . . this will.” “(Summa Theologiae, III, 83, 4).

After the consecration, the priest “asks that the sacrifice accomplished may find favor with God, when he says: “Look down upon them with a propitious,” etc.”(Ib.).

11. In Eucharistic Prayer III the offering is expressed with the following words uttered by the popular consecration: “Look, we pray, upon the oblation of your Church and, recognizing the sacrificial Victim by whose death you willed to reconcile us to yourself, grant that we, who are nourished by the Body and Blood of your Son and filled with his Holy Spirit, may become one body, one spirit in Christ.

May he make of us an eternal offering to you, … “.

12. From what you tell me in the Neocatechumenal celebration, the offertory has almost gone unnoticed.

John Paul II in Dominicae cenae instead recalls its meaning: “Consequently, the celebrant, as minister of this sacrifice, is the authentic priest, performing-in virtue of the specific power of-sacred ordination-a true sacrificial act that brings creation back to God. Although all those who participate in the Eucharist do not confect the sacrifice as He does, they offer with Him, by virtue of the common priesthood, their own spiritual sacrifices represented by the bread and wine from the moment of their presentation at the altar. For this liturgical action, which takes a solemn form in almost all liturgies, has a “spiritual value and meaning.” The bread and wine become in a sense a symbol of all that the eucharistic assembly brings, on its own part, as an offering to God and offers spiritually.

It is important that this first moment of the Liturgy of the Eucharist in the strict sense should find expression in the attitude of the participants. There is a link between this and the offertory “procession” provided for in the recent liturgical reform and accompanied, in keeping with ancient tradition, by a psalm or song. A certain length of time must be allowed, so that all can become aware of this act, which is given expression at the same time by the words of the celebrant.” (DC, 9).

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to remember important truths of our Christian faith.

I will gladly remember you, your wife and your dearest first-born in Mass this evening.

In the meantime, I wish you all the best and bless you.

Father Angelo

2019, November 28th | A priest answers – Liturgy and pastoral care – Liturgical section

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian