Question
In the long term, is atheism likely to cause a terrible feeling of lack of consistency concerning creatures and the creation? As if one was unable to see anything good in anything and anybody, or as if everything, including ourselves, were to disappear at any moment? A feeling by which man is seen as a creature at the mercy of his own instincts (led by pitiless and malign inwardness) as well as at the mercy of the external world led by nature which is of merciless and fickle and which alternates natural disasters and climatic adversities. Could such feelings be prompted by the devil’s suggestions, given that they seem like the prelude of hell? Yet both creatures and creation bear the trace of God, therefore they must have kept something good about them, in spite of the impairment brought about by sin. Nevertheless, it is hard to perceive that everything talks about God. Do sins only cloud the conscience or can they also damage the human psyche?
The priest’s answer
Dear,
- You write that atheism, in the long run, can cause a terrible feeling of lack of consistency that involves both creatures and creation. Yes, it is true, atheism leads to the insignificance of all things and of life itself. Should life be worth nothing, why should we still talk about good and evil, fair and unfair?
- Man cannot find the meaning and the very dignity of his own life if he disregards his origin and his purpose. The Second Vatican Council fittingly reminds that “without the Creator the creature would disappear” (Gaudium et spes, 36).
- The same Council affirms that “The root reason for human dignity lies in man’s call to communion with God” (GS, 19).
- I think that, among physical impairments, the most serious one is being deprived of eyesight. Analogously, the greatest misfortune that can befall a person is failing to know himself or herself, his or her origin and his or her purpose. When one is innerly blind he is just like a blind person, who is immersed in an environment fraught with hidden hazards and, if left alone, he cannot but fall into mortal dangers. For this reason, the Second Vatican Council says that “when divine instruction and the hope of life eternal are lacking , man’s dignity is most grievously lacerated” (GS 21). It is what you claim when you write that atheism “is a feeling by which man is seen as a creature at the mercy of his own instincts (led by pitiless and malign inwardness) as well as at the mercy of the external world that is led by nature which is merciless and fickle and which alternates natural disasters and climatic adversities”.
- 5. And, what is worst, according to atheism “riddles of life and death, of guilt and of grief go unsolved with the frequent result that men succumb to despair. Meanwhile every man remains to himself an unsolved puzzle, however obscurely he may perceive it. For on certain occasions no one can entirely escape the kind of self-questioning mentioned earlier, especially when life’s major events take place” (GS 21).
- The Council then adds, using a benevolent and euphemistic language: “[man] cannot live fully according to truth unless he freely acknowledges that love and devotes himself to His Creator” (GS 19). Not living fully according to the truth means to fall short of many things and to miss many things. For this reason the Council, following what Saint Paul says in the Epistle to the Romans 1:20, states that “undeniably, those who willfully shut out God from their hearts and try to dodge religious questions are not following the dictates of their consciences, and hence are not free of blame” (GS 19).
- Finally, you ask if sins can damage not only one’s conscience, but also one’s psyche. When sin is so deeply rooted in people that it alters their conscience and disfigures it to the point that their glory is in their shame, as Saint Paul says (cfr. Ph. 3:19, t.n.) , then there is also an alteration of the psyche, although the subject is not aware of this.
- For this reason, even though the Council remembers that “conscience frequently errs from invincible ignorance without losing its dignity” (GS 16), it adds that “The same cannot be said for a man who cares but little for truth and goodness, or for a conscience which by degrees grows practically sightless as a result of habitual sin” (ibidem).
- You also say that “creatures and the creation bear the trace of God, therefore they must have kept something good about them, in spite of the impairment brought about by sin. Nevertheless, it is hard to perceive that everything talks about God”. I believe that it depends a lot on the inner health of the subject. If his eye is healthy, he will distinguish the colours clearly and sharply. If his eye is unhealthy, he will have a hard time seeing. Saint Augustine used to say about himself: “ the heaven and the earth and all that therein is, lo, on every side, they call me to love Thee, nor do they cease to call to all ‘that they may be without excuse’ (Rom 1:20, e.n.)” (Confessions, X, 6, 8).
Thank you for asking the question. I remember you to the Lord in my prayers and I bless you.
Father Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

