Dear Father Angelo,

I am Aronne.

I recently learned that when Pope Pius IX proclaimed the dogma of the Immaculate Conception, the Franciscans and Benedictines were in favor, while the Dominicans were not!

I was a little upset to learn this, considering that I have been a Dominican tertiary for several years, and then to learn that the great St. Thomas Aquinas did not want to talk about such a subject!

I look forward to your response.

Thank you.

Response from the priest

Dear Aronne,

First of all, I would like to express my pleasure at coming into contact with a Dominican tertiary.

Getting to the point, I must say that at the time of Pius IX everything had already been clarified and that the Dominicans were now essentially in favor of proclaiming the dogma.

But we must recognize that historically the Dominicans were opposed to this truth.

This is how things went.

1. At first, St. Thomas, as can be seen from his early works, was in favor of the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception of the Virgin.

But when some people drew from this statement the conclusion that Our Lady had not been redeemed by Christ, he denied her exemption from original sin.

St. Paul says, in fact, that in Adam’s sin all have sinned and therefore all have needed Christ’s redemption: “Through the disobedience of one man all have been made sinners” (Rom 5:19), and “Just as through one man sin entered the world, and through sin death, so also death came to all men, because all sinned” (Rom 5:12).

St. Thomas therefore affirmed that Mary, immediately after her conception, received an extraordinary sanctification in her soul, which erased original sin.

At the end of his life, when he was preaching Lent in Naples, he returned to the position he had defended in his youth.

2. Few people know about a post-mortem intervention by St. Thomas on this subject.

St. Alphonsus Liguori writes: “Caramuel reports a revelation made by St. Thomas Aquinas to the Venerable Dominic of Jesus Mary, Superior General of the Carmelites, in which he told him that in a future council the Church would define the truth about the Immaculate Conception of the Virgin. Suarez and Vasquaez also assert this…” (St. Alphonsus Liguori, Teologia moralis, lib, VII, n. 251).

The truth was not defined in a council, but it was defined nonetheless.

3. It must be said that before St. Thomas, great saints and devotees of Mary denied her immaculate conception, including St. Bernard and St. Albert the Great.

4. So this is how things went.

The Church took St. Thomas’s thinking into account, and in Pius IX’s definition we read that “Mary, in anticipation of Christ’s merits, was redeemed in a singular way.”

In other words, a pre-redemption was enacted for her.

Thank you for your question. Best regards.

I promise to remember you in my prayers and bless you.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian