Question
Dear Father,
For some time, I have been reflecting on the lightness with which many people choose to cohabit instead of getting married.
I find that many women, to prove themselves emancipated and independent, accept living together and having children, thinking “it doesn’t change anything; it’s like being married.”
They seem to want to ridicule those, like me, who, despite being over 30, continue to value their principles and, in respect of the education received from their parents, have never cohabited and never will.
For me, marriage does not represent the possibility of being supported—because fortunately, I lack nothing—but the fulfillment of a great love, based on respect, planning, and the desire to honor the other person.
Yes, because I do not want to be regarded like an appliance to be tested and possibly married after years of sin, nor do I want to consider my partner as such.
In this regard, I am in a relationship with a man who has cohabited in the past, and I must admit that when I think about it, I instinctively consider him inferior to me.
From the beginning, I told him that I have never cohabited and never will: I would prefer to live single until the last day of my life rather than disrespect myself.
If I find myself forced to leave him because he does not decide to ask me to marry him (I do not intend to wait for years), how could I regain trust and hope in love and the possibility of fulfilling my dream of marriage? It would come naturally for me to give up on it forever.
Thank you,
Roberta
Priest’s answer
Dear Roberta,
1. It is a fact that premarital cohabitation is widespread. Many are convinced that it is a valid experience. Although often burned by its dissolution, they quickly begin another. The topic of chastity hardly crosses their minds, as if it were not the path that strengthens and stabilizes love.
2. How many times, alongside people who come to the priest crying over the end of their cohabitation, does one feel compelled to repeat what Jesus said while weeping over Jerusalem from the Mount of Olives: “If you, even you, had only recognized on this day the things that make for peace! But now they are hidden from your eyes.” (Lk 19:42).
3. The real problem, even before cohabitation, lies in the way of thinking and living sexuality. Cohabitation in most cases is the logical consequence of a wrong lifestyle that has been adopted for some time, in which sexuality is mostly lived as a playful experience that feels good at the moment.
4. More fundamentally, there is an eclipse of the horizon or of the meaning of life being lived without understanding its ultimate purpose, in light of the carpe diem (seize the day) philosophy of the ancient Romans.
5. It is true that the values you speak of and have chosen as your lifestyle can be perceived even outside of faith. Among these are also those specific to marriage. However, outside of a religious perspective, they remain significantly weakened. Only the goal of sanctification, which is not optional and is indeed the non-negotiable aim to pursue for eternal salvation, gives the strength to be faithful in good times and bad to the commitment made on the day of the wedding.
6. But this goal is largely misunderstood. Pope Saint John Paul II said that it is necessary to establish a pedagogy of holiness and that our Christian communities, starting from parishes, must be characterized by this objective. In the last years of his pontificate, youth meetings were often marked by “duc in altum” (Lk 5:4), which literally means: go higher, as high as you can.
7. Today purity seems to have disappeared even from the words of the Magisterium, forgetting that only in purity can wisdom be found, and thus God can be found. It is written in Sirach: “I directed my soul to her, and in purity I found her.” (Sir 51:20).
8. The post-synodal exhortation Amoris Laetitia speaks of cohabitation as a lifestyle adopted by many. If someone expected a bit more vigor on this subject to help families and educators, they were disappointed.
The document merely recognizes that “in many countries there is a legal deconstruction of the family that tends to adopt forms based almost exclusively on the paradigm of autonomy of will” (AL 53).
However, it acknowledges that only the family—and implicitly a family based on marriage—can produce true love that is faithful, indissoluble, and open to life. And that “the strength of the family resides essentially in its ability to love and teach how to love” (AL 53).
9. More incisive is the Directory for Family Pastoral Care from the Italian Bishops’ Conference (CEI): “Even though contemporary culture tends to legitimize these cohabitations, the Church cannot but reaffirm that they are in contrast with the deep meaning of conjugal love: it is never an experiment and always involves a total gift of self to the other; it requires recognition and social legitimization and, for Christians, also ecclesial legitimization” (n. 227).
With the hope that your testimony may be contagious for many, I bless you and remember you in my prayers.
Padre Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

