Hi, Father Angelo,

I admit I am very confused, and I do not hide the fact that I am bitter too because every priest has his own say. But the Church is one, isn’t it? The Catechism of the Catholic Church is one, isn’t it?

My confusion is so much, not because of believers, but, let me say so, because of God’s ministers.

Let me explain what happened to me.

On a Sunday, I was on vacation at my beach house. My guests stayed so late that my wife, daughter, and I forgot to keep holy that Sunday. We did not go to Mass because we forgot to.

The next day, I contacted my parish priest via message, who advised me to go to confession as soon as possible, but in the meantime, I should not deprive myself of communion when I go to Mass, even without confession. 

I followed his advice, and so I did. 

I went to confess for various reasons to another priest, who reproached me, saying that was not necessary! And that I live my faith with too many constraints and laws that the Church has wrongly given us over the years! 

That priest told me that at the judgement by Jesus, He will not ask me why I did not go to Mass that Sunday, but He will ask me how I had behaved towards others. 

And, that I am like a Pharisee bound by the laws, but Jesus was human and understands our shortcomings and is merciful. 

In short, he really scolded me! 

I am confused; did I do wrong? Did I exaggerate by going to confession? 

Then he concluded that coming to the confessional every 15 days without having committed any serious sins is excessive!


The Priest’s answer 

Dear,

1. Above the opinions of individual priests, we have the doctrine and discipline of the Church as presented to us in the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

2. Regarding the forgetfulness: it is true that you had guests and that it was getting late.

But it would have been appropriate to plan your actions, ensuring your attendance at Mass, perhaps by attending on Saturday evening.

3. In any case, the thought of Mass should have been dominant for you throughout Sunday.

It could also have been a good opportunity to tell your guests that you had to go to Mass and that you would have been happy if they would join you in case they had not attended yet.

4. Your parish priest was understanding and, finding no grave fault in the forgetfulness, he told you to confess that and, in the meantime, to receive Communion.

You obeyed him, and you did right.

5. Instead, the priest you turned to for confession had a superficial behavior.

It was not his role to say that the Church erred by issuing certain laws and that you live your faith with too many constraints.

Rather, while acknowledging the diminished responsibility, he should have been pleased with your commitment to living the Christian life seriously, exempting yourself from nothing and with the desire to always put God first.

6. A young man asked Jesus what he ought to do in order to inherit eternal life, and He replied: “Keep the commandments.” Among these, evidently, is the third: “Remember to keep holy the feasts.”

Furthermore, when instituting the Eucharist, the Lord said: “Do this in memory of me.”

And the Church, from the beginning by apostolic tradition, has replaced the Sabbath with Sunday, seeing at the Lord’s Resurrection.

It is a very great memory, which He communicates His power to us in, through the celebration of the Eucharist.

7. He was again superficial in saying that one confession every 15 days is excessive.

This priest knows that the Church requires priests and religious to confess frequently, meaning at least twice a month.

Which means every 15 days.

Why should not permit lay people to receive this sacrament as frequently as he does?

Thank God for having your parish priest, and always abide to the doctrine and discipline of the Church.

I bless you.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish