Question
Dear Father,
I would like to ask you this question. How can a justified search for self-confidence and the catholic moral coexist?
The meaning of “effectiveness”, which means confidence in your own ability to solve problems and to face unpredictable situations is one of the most important elements in enhancing one’s self esteem. The idea behind the “effectiveness” can increase if, when I reach something, I can give credit to internal causes which means to myself and to my actions. But my self-confidence can’t increase if the catholic moral teaches me to be humble, to thank God for my success, to realize how useless I am compared to Him. On the contrary, in the case of a failure, the Doctrine teaches me that God is totally “out of it” as He doesn’t want bad things for us. So, the failure’s cause would be internal, which means that it would be mine. This idea doesn’t help to nourish my self-confidence.
Moreover, self esteem is linked to a detailed analysis of what others think about us. This obviously leads us to put ourselves at the center of our own attention and to live, as much as possible, as our own god. It is the opposite of what a good christian should do. Thinking of us as “a useless God’s servant”, just to directly quote a biblical expression, is in contrast to the path we should follow.
In conclusion, trying to reach a goal is often a synonym of a challenge with other people. It means to prevail against or beat another person. If we obtain that those around us have a high consideration of ourselves, it also entails us to feel somehow superior to others. To me, it seems to clash with the words “love your neighbor as yourself”.
I thank you a lot.
Paolo
Answer
Dear Paolo,
1. Today we talk a lot about self esteem. You have highlighted that is not so similar to the evangelical teachings which lead us to humility and to being considered as useless servants. But it is not right.
2. In self esteem, we should recognize what is right and what is wrong.
3. Self esteem also means the need to recognize the talents God has given us which we should manage and this is all part of the evangelical perspective. We know God will ask us to account for what we didn’t want to do. The parable of the talents clearly explains it (Mt 25, 14-30).
4. Being humble doesn’t mean not recognizing the gifts or talents that God has given us. St. Paul knew the gifts He received. He stated: “But what anyone dares to boast of (I am speaking in foolishness) I also dare. Are they Hebrews? So am I. Are they Israelites? So am I. Are they descendants of Abraham? So am I. Are they ministers of Christ? (I am talking like an insane person.) I am still more, with far greater labors, far more imprisonments, far worse beatings, and numerous brushes with death” (2 Cor 11, 21-23).
But he knows that all of this doesn’t come from himself, but from God. And for that, he states: “What do you possess that you have not received? But if you have received it, why are you boasting as if you did not receive it?” (1 Cor 4, 7) and “Whoever boasts, should boast in the Lord” (2 Cor 10, 17).
5. It may be useful to remember that true christians don’t trust only their natural abilities (which are a God’s gift, too), but also supernatural ones. For that reason they are never upset and they can agree with St Paul: “I have the strength for everything through him who empowers me” (Phil 4, 13). I may say that nothing but the Gospels can increase self-confidence
6. Competition in business, in contests, in races isn’t the opposite of christian humility. It would be the opposite only if the purpose was to enjoy other people’s humiliation. But if it is only about sharing your good qualities with others, why not? Why shouldn’t you exploit your good qualities during a football match to give glory to God and provide enjoyment to the watchers? Not doing it, it would be a loss.
7. This is not in contrast with considering us as useless servants, because all we have is thanks to God, not to ourselves. A ray of sun would be silly to brag about its own beauty.
8. All of what you wrote is human, and so it has some clear limits that in the end may result in making those who remain behind feel depressed. The aim of a challenge is not humiliation or other people’s failure, but it is to make good and positive things win. People who lose admit it by saying: “I give credit to the winners”. They say it also to improve themselves.
9. Humility is not in contrast with the fulfilment of exceptional deeds, either. All of the great Saints, especially the ones moved by charity, obtain extraordinary accomplishments that still remain. But they were very humble, exactly like the One who created heavens and lands and that stated: “learn from me, for I am meek and humble of heart; and you will find rest for yourselves” (Mt 11, 29). I thank you for the question, I remember you to the Lord and I bless you.
Padre Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

