Dear Father Angelo,

I wanted to ask you a question to which the various priests I interviewed responded differently:

Was Maria ever tempted?

On a rational level, the answer obviously appears YES as a creature, but intuitively I feel that the devil has never approached Her.

In communion of prayer and thanks.

Antonio

Priest’s response

Dear Antonio,

1. the Blessed Virgin was the person most similar to Christ. And if Christ was subject to temptation, the same thing must also be said of Mary.

However, the temptations that struck Jesus did not drag Him towards evil, as unfortunately can happen for us.

Something similar to what refers to emotions or passions happened with the temptations of Jesus.

While in us the emotions “do not stop at the sensitive sphere, but drag the reason”, in Christ it never happened that “his reason was hindered in the slightest”. In fact, in Him everything was perfectly dominated by the will (Saint Thomas, Summa theologica, III, 15, 4).

The same thing must be said of the Blessed Virgin Mary, who was by singular privilege exempted from original sin and disordered lusts.

Every temptation in her was a reason to go even further, while in us temptations often leave some wounds.

2. Another thing should also be noted.

Christ underwent three temptations: that of doing miraculous things (that the stones became bread), that of throwing himself off the pinnacle of the temple because God would save him (vainglory), and that of possessing riches and human kingdoms.

In other words, Jesus was tempted only by realities that came from outside.

However, He was not tempted by what comes from within us. To be clear, He was not tempted into the lust of the flesh.

We, however, are tempted from without and from within.

Listen to what St. Thomas says: “The temptation that comes from the enemy can be without sin, since in itself it consists of a pure external suggestion. However, the temptation of the flesh cannot be without sin, since it derives from pleasure and concupiscence; and according to St. Augustine there is always something sinful when the flesh has desires contrary to those of the spirit (De Civitate Dei 19,4), Thus therefore Christ wanted to be tempted by the enemy, but not by the flesh” (Summa theologica , III, 41, 1, ad 3).

Well, the same thing must be said of Mary, who, according to a beautiful statement by Saint Lawrence of Brindisi, is very similar to Jesus (Simillima Jesu).

Your expression “The devil never approached Mary” must be understood in the sense that he could not cause even the slightest imperfection in her.

But it should not be understood in the sense that he did not subject her to temptation, because in this respect the devil even approached the Lord. The Gospel of Matthew says: “The tempter then approached Him” (Mt 4:3).

I thank you for the communion of prayers which I willingly reciprocate and bless you.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian