Question

Hello Father Angelo,

Given the Christmas period and since we live  in Puglia (Apulia) we have just made a pilgrimage to San Giovanni Rotondo to go to  Saint Pio as I am very devoted to him.  When we were in the church we met a friar who was talking to some pilgrims about the saint and so we started to listen to him…. The friar said something that struck me  about St. Pio who  had kept the  grace of baptism throughout  his life… which should mean (if I get it correctly) that the saint had  never committed a mortal sin! Moreover he said that the expression  “full of Grace” that is said to the Blessed Mother Mary could also be referred to the saint of Pietrelcina since he had never committed serious sins. These statements have left me perplexed …

Is it possible that Saint Pius or any other saint, (except obviously  for Our Lady and Jesus) had never committed a mortal sin all their  life?

Merry Christmas (2017)


Answer from the priest

Dear friend,

1. There are not a few who lived their whole life  keeping intact the grace of Baptism without ever committing any grave sin.

2. Here are some records. 

First of all, here is what is witnessed about Saint Dominic. In a prayer written by  Blessed Jordan of Saxony who was elected as his successor as Master General of the Order we read: “In the first flower of your age you dedicated your virgin soul to the comely Spouse of virgins. In your baptismal innocence, shining with the grace of the Holy Spirit, you devoted your soul in fervent love to the King of kings.[…] Your  body you offered as “a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing unto God.” After all, St. Dominic himself on his deathbed had said to the friars present: “My children, God’s mercy has kept me pure flesh and a spotless virginity to this day. It is the custody of this virtue that makes the servant of God pleasing to Christ and that gives him glory and credit before men ”.

3. Secondly, here is what is recorded about Saint Gemma Galgani.

 In a beautiful biography of this Saint ,  some excerpts from the report written by Father Pietro Paolo, confessor of the Saint, are reported by Father Germano Ruoppolo in which we read: “I have heard her confess her sins  several times, and in 1901 Gemma asked and obtained from her spiritual father Archbishop  Volpi to come to me for  a general confession,  in order to prepare herself  even better to  purchase  indulgences on the occasion of  the Holy Jubilee. This confession was highly sought after by her, and was accomplished three times; and I was able to know that that creature of God had kept her Baptismal  innocence “(Saint Gemma Galgani, p. 96). Father Germano notes: “It is hardly necessary to remember that innocence, like virtues and  gifts are not  matter of the sacramental seal as sins are; and thus we understand the reason why  the confessors of the Servants of God never had scruples to manifest them after the death of their penitent saints. (see Ballerini -Palmieri, n. 952 et seq.). Ballerini and Palmieri are two  great Jesuit moral theologians of the second half of the 19th century.

4. The third record is about  Saint Teresa of the Child Jesus, who became a Carmelite.

Shortly after becoming a Carmelite  she had the grace to make her general confession with the spiritual father of the monastery. Here is her report:

“My conversation with this good Father would have brought me great comfort, had it not been for the extreme difficulty. I found in opening my heart. Nevertheless I made a general confession, and after it he said to  me: “Before God, the Blessed Virgin, and Angels, and all the Saints, I declare that you have never committed a mortal sin. Thank God for the favours He has so freely bestowed on you without any merit on your part.”

Without any merit on my part! That was not difficult to believe. Fully conscious of my weakness and imperfection, my heart overflowed with gratitude. I had distressed myself, fearing I might have stained my baptismal robe, and this assurance, coming as it did from the lips of a director, a man of wisdom and holiness, such as our Mother St. Teresa desired, seemed to come from God Himself. Father Pichon added: “May Our Lord always be your Superior and your Novice Master!” And indeed He ever was, and likewise my Director. “(Story of a soul, 196 Pages 72-73).

5. In my experience as a confessor I can assure you that I have met people who have kept the grace of Baptism intact.There are some even today among young people. It is to be hoped that they will keep it forever without ever overestimating themselves according to the admonition of St. Paul: “Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall.” (1 Cor 10:12).

6. The second statement  of the good Capuchin friar must be well understood,  without creating ambiguity. Our Lady is full of Grace above all because She  was exempted from original sin from the very first moment of Her  existence. Secondly, because God poured out on Her   such a degree of holiness which He  did not pour out on the whole Church, as He wanted  to make her a second Eve, the universal Mother of each one of He  children. The special veneration due  to Her, known as hyperdulia, is higher than the cultus dulia (veneration) due to those who serve God, namely angels and other saints.  Padre Pio had holiness to an eminent degree. Someone called him a giant of holiness. But the holiness of Padre Pio remains  within the circle of the ministering servants of God, the first place of which is occupied by St. Joseph. Padre Pio was also infected with original sin, from which he was freed through  Baptism. Padre Pio is also among those who, because of human frailty, were lightly touched by venial sin or imperfections and for this he made use of the Sacrament  of Penance, that is, he went to confession. Only Our Lady was exempted from it due to  a singular privilege because She  had to become the Mother of God. Of course, the fact that Padre Pio never committed a grave sin makes us understand that he had such a degree of God’s gracein him that he could never yield to sin  and that in this he was similar to the sun which in its progress is like a giant that travels its way ( cf. Ps 9: 6).

While I wish you Padre Pio’s blessing, I remember you in my prayers and I bless you.

Father Angelo

Questo articolo è disponibile anche in: Italian Spanish French Portuguese