Good evening.
I wanted to know: if a person dies in a state of attrition and not perfect contrition, is he saved according to the Church?
Thank you in advance for your kind reply.
Priest’s answer
Dear Livio,
1. Attrition or imperfect contrition means sorrow for sins because one has lost the state of grace, exposing oneself to demonic incursions, to evil spells, and to eternal damnation.
In a word, it is sorrow for all that one has lost and for all the evil to which one can be subjected.
2. According to Catholic theology, attrition is the fruit of actual grace, that is, one of those graces, those interior movements, those illuminations with which God accompanies sinners to lead them to conversion.
You may have noticed the expression: it is the fruit of actual grace, that is, a divine favor granted at a specific moment.
3. Furthermore, it not only originates from God, but is also of a supernatural order.
It is therefore given for the sake of eternal salvation, and its purpose is to prepare the soul to receive an even greater good, that of perfect contrition.
4. Attrition, however, is not yet sufficient to reconcile with God and enter into communion with Him.
This, instead, is the fruit of perfect contrition, by which one regrets not only having lost God’s grace and exposed oneself to so many evils, but above all because the Lord has been crucified anew in our hearts (cf. Heb 6:6) and because He who is worthy of being loved above all things has been banished from our soul.
This regret, in addition to being of a supernatural order and of divine origin, also reunites us with God, giving rise to the resolve to do everything He has provided to bring about this reconciliation, including the resolve to approach the sacrament of confession.
5. The Council of Trent says about imperfect sorrow: “That imperfect contrition which is called attrition, which is commonly conceived either from the consideration of the ugliness of sin or from the fear of hell and its punishments, if it excludes the will to sin with the hope of forgiveness, not only does not make man a hypocrite and a greater sinner, but is a gift of God and an impulse of the Holy Spirit, who certainly does not yet dwell in the soul, but only moves it; with the help of this impulse the penitent prepares for himself the way of justice. And although attrition without the sacrament of Penance cannot in itself lead the sinner to justification, nevertheless it disposes him to implore the grace of God in the sacrament of Penance. For the Ninevites, usefully shaken from this fear by the terrifying preaching of Jonah, did penance and implored mercy from the Lord (cf. Jonah 3)” (DS 1678). T-N
6. For this reason, the Catechism of the Catholic Church summarizes it thus: “Such a stirring of conscience can initiate an interior process which, under the prompting of grace, will be brought to completion by sacramental absolution. By itself however, imperfect contrition cannot obtain the forgiveness of grave sins, but it disposes one to obtain forgiveness in the sacrament of Penance. (DS 1677)” (CCC 1453).
7. Therefore, attrition alone does not obtain forgiveness of grave sins and does not obtain the state of grace, because it is a momentary or actual grace.
Therefore, the soul remains in mortal sin.
Only the habitual state of grace sanctifies the soul.
Precisely for this reason it is called sanctifying grace.
Only this grace allows one to enter among the saints in heaven.
With the hope of always living in the state of grace and perfect contrition, I bless you and remember you in prayer.
Father Angelo
Questo articolo è disponibile anche in:

